He was discussing PPP - very rare vs PPD . One in the literature review is shortly after birth due to intense hormonal changes and usually resolves after 6 weeks. I hope that helps.
2026-08-23 20:55:33
0
Hunnielove28 :
Not only that PPD can last up to 7 years
2026-08-25 09:22:51
0
Lauren, Aesthetic Injector RN :
And that breastfeeding or stopping it can cause significant hormonal and emotional changes for a long period of time
2026-08-24 00:31:05
3
Lemons866 :
He was quoting the DSM V which is the most recent version of the diagnostic bible. It wasn’t even his opinion …
2026-08-24 23:06:54
0
Jasper :
His testimony worked against the prosecution by showing how women’s mental health is belittled.
2026-08-22 18:59:13
38
PostpartumPatroness :
Very disappointing we know more than healthcare PROFESSIONALS 😳
2026-08-23 03:18:12
6
Natalie :
The whole country got a front row seat for how women are treated in a healthcare system designed for men
2026-08-23 07:44:59
5
Lann1019 :
When he stated 4 weeks he was going by what the DSM V states, not personal opinion.
2026-08-22 16:19:30
17
❤️🇺🇸It's Trish...Bish🇺🇸❤️ :
PPD is literally depression within the postpartum period. Now... what he said was that the physiological changes that can lead to postpartum PSYCHOSIS are due to changes within the the body that occur within the first 4 weeks of giving birth. Comprehension is key. Now evidence does indicate that psychosis can continue on beyond that point, but Lindsay had zero symptoms til September.
2026-08-22 19:06:07
9
slitch1988 :
You guys clearly don’t watch the trial. Not once did he say PP symptoms last 4 weeks 😂😂
2026-08-23 14:24:39
0
Just a chill goy :
"Without treatment." She was one of the most well treated ppl on the planet.
2026-08-22 15:46:40
5
makdelo :
As much as you guys don’t like him, that man is an expert witness in forensic psychiatry and frankly a genius in his field. He was hired to get on the stand and state the facts, and according to the DSM5 he did just that.
2026-08-23 22:11:35
0
ConnorWasPerfect :
So we can all play doctors when defending a woman that killed her children but we can’t have an opinion on the vaccine?
2026-08-22 22:05:57
2
Growing with Grief :
That’s great, but as a psychiatrist, he doesn’t diagnose through the what ACOG wants, the only psychiatric diagnoses in the US come from the DSM.
2026-08-23 00:33:08
2
🤘❌🎸🍴🥘 Cindy in Texas ❌🤘 :
Not addressing the postpartum issue because we know his BS about that was BS, but by the time he said a tear was called an episiotomy, I was so done with him that I yelled at the TV. I have birth records with tearing in both of my children (not bad tearing though, so my experience would have been much less unpleasant than many other women & I don’t discount that), but even with notes of the tearing, not one place in my records does it say I had an episiotomy. ‘Repairs’ of tears with one child (the other so minor it didn’t require anything, yes. Episiotomy, no!
2026-08-22 20:22:26
1
Kristen 💕🎀 :
That man should not be in charge of evaluation any woman in a mental health crisis. The prosecution should be embarrassed for bringing him on the stand.
2026-08-22 13:59:57
6
Renèe Des :
I had an episiotomy. Before she cut me with scissors, she used her finger NAIL to try to rip me more. And then she took scissors to me because she “didn’t believe in c section.” I got 223 stitches, 3 layers. I was 16.
2026-08-22 18:34:51
6
Kimi :
I had both with my first kid cut and tear because she was sunny side up. Still haunts me
2026-08-22 23:32:47
1
K_halla :
He’s not a medical doctor. Psych doctors don’t manage patients medically so not surprised he’s not 100% on things like episiotomy’s
2026-08-23 00:21:53
1
Eddie Pena452 :
omg he didn't agree with woman so he wrong 💯💯
2026-08-22 18:28:27
1
Growing with Grief :
Also- episiotomies are usually done when the start of a “natural” tear begins. That’s how I understood his response. The fact that this is the one thing people are stuck on shows that Mack was definitely on top of that exchange
2026-08-23 00:31:42
2
jeffspooville :
I believe the defense team and the prosecution, she did it. The rest is the juries problem. Both sides have failed. I guess the jury will have to make a judgement on the DSM 5 standard.
2026-08-22 16:17:55
1
Nobody10 :
Which one of her SEVERAL doctors failed to treat her.
2026-08-23 12:52:21
3
Elle :
The state of MA health care guidelines lists postpartum as the 12 months following BIRTH!! And he’s not even licensed in the state of MA so how was he allowed to evaluate her??
2026-08-23 03:24:11
4
To see more videos from user @allthingsemz, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.