Michelle :
She’s innocent. Reddington’s strategy: He originally asked for a bifurcated trial—two phases: first, whether the prosecution could prove Lindsay committed the acts & whether she was criminally responsible given her mental state. The judge denied it, saying the evidence overlaps too much to separate.
Because of that, Reddington’s strategy has essentially been to focus on criminal responsibility/insanity rather than simply arguing “Lindsay didn’t do it.” That doesn’t mean he believes she did it. It means he’s pursuing what gives her the safest legal outcome: the jury could find her not guilty or not criminally responsible because of her mental illness.
He also cannot just flat out blame Patrick. Reddington agreed in filings not to pursue a third-party culprit defense, so he can’t simply argue that Patrick did it. The investigation focused so heavily on Lindsay that it’s difficult to build an alternative culprit case this late; much evidence is unavailable or untestable (house sold, kids cremated, new phone).
That’s why I think people are missing the bigger picture when they say, “She confessed, so case closed.” Her statements have to be considered in the context of her mental state, head injury, medication & mental illness. Much of what she said was inconsistent with the physical evidence, & the prosecution’s own witness said she didn’t know what happened when she woke up & had to be told. (claimed she cut the window screen, but it was never cut)
The defense has exposed problems with the investigation & evidence that was lost or impossible to test by the time Reddington became involved. The judge declined to give the jury the Bowden instruction about those issues because it goes against his agreement to avoid “third-party culprit.” (But now reasonable doubt)
And then there’s the civil lawsuit alleging medical professionals failed her, so the defense must be careful how they characterize what happened.
Bottom line: you can’t take Reddington’s current strategy & automatically interpret it as “he believes Lindsay did it.” He’s working within the case’s limitations & rulings while trying to give Lindsay the best path to avoid a murder conviction.
2026-08-27 04:41:54