@lthlnkso: Is JK Rowling a good author? (Objectively, obviously) @Ty

Quick Thoughts
Quick Thoughts
Open In TikTok:
Region: US
Saturday 29 August 2026 17:51:22 GMT
160249
10869
3308
234

Music

Download

Comments

ghostieszs
ghostieszs :
Nice try, but he said his view is objective, thereby invalidating your data.
2026-08-29 18:02:01
4163
mrpetenutbutter
Pete from Malört & Savior :
I cannot stand when people say “objectively” to mean “I feel very strongly about this”
2026-08-29 20:31:53
1350
chisel_maxxing
ultimate_endurance :
He's just angry because Rowling believes a woman is specifically a biological adult female.
2026-08-29 20:16:08
1531
kupferdach
Kupferdach :
popular ≠ good
2026-08-30 06:10:06
362
wilib0y
Will :
You don’t understand — he emphasizes all of his consonant sounds, which means he’s smart and right about everything
2026-08-29 18:23:41
1286
gamer_trex
gamer_trex :
“I hate the artist so the art must be bad” 💀
2026-08-29 20:20:16
842
cameronmartin06
Cameron Martin :
He's objectively wrong in his use of the word objective
2026-08-29 22:25:47
424
scrollcrazy
Scrollcrazy :
Objectively, say less
2026-08-29 18:50:59
354
verylittleinsipiration
jejdjdjdkslskswjjsk :
Defeats Voldemort? Put a spoiler warning next time, dude 🙄
2026-08-29 18:03:21
443
davdave0
Dav Dave :
appealing to sales and popularity is never ever a strong argument for the merit of art. also gesturing at rejection in an art field is ridiculous. piercing the veil of publication is a .01% feet that speaks nothing to quality and everything to vendibility. this guy is just guffawing because he hates jk Rowling as a person but if there are objective metrics by which the artistry of writing can be evaluated, neither of you are interrogating them. this is by far the weakest argument I've ever heard you present which is only to say I like you and am not a routine hater of your work.
2026-08-30 03:52:47
38
anime4sd
anime4sd :
🙄🙄🙄🙄 Good writing is not meassured in how often is it read.
2026-08-29 21:20:39
34
thevaevictisbd
VaeVictisBD :
'Most Read' doesn't mean 'Most Good.' He's still correct in saying it's objectively bad.
2026-08-30 00:19:39
19
jake_son_fantasy
Jake-son-Fantasy📚✝️ :
He literally just explained why your argument isn’t addressing what he said. They’re popular, yes. In terms of the traditional definition of well written literature, they suck.
2026-08-31 01:15:55
10
lore_maker
lore_maker :
we're in the big 26 and yall think popularity is a metric of quality? that I'm itself is incoherent as a baseline. it's like arguing what people eat the most equates to how healthy it is and you see mac Donald's topping the charts and then asserting it is the healthiest option avaliable. "they're saying this fast food restaurant is bad for your health because insurmountable amount of health risks but its clearly objectively good for you because of the amount time spend in them". I'm not really supporting the other guy as his argument shouldn't have been so vague but this video is objectively much worst as the sole argumentation is "more popular = more good"
2026-08-30 07:46:25
20
samuraisarebetter
👾 :
Ok so your whole defense is solely based on the popularity of the books?
2026-08-30 15:14:02
6
petalsettle
Petal :
You’re confusing popularity with quality 👍
2026-08-30 08:02:33
14
ryans5302
ryans5302 :
30 seconds into the video and your already making an argumentum ad populum (popularity fallacy)
2026-08-29 20:42:57
18
leerob09
Rob Lee :
most people eat junk food. and it's not good for you.
2026-08-29 22:24:00
6
grayravecrave
Gray :
Popularity does not make the books well written. They aren’t.
2026-08-29 21:47:41
621
ethrithdiuo
yahoo :
Popular does not mean good tho does it
2026-08-31 10:35:23
12
beau27108
Beau :
Most read does not = good.
2026-08-30 02:36:57
196
dinfoiltildo
🌈⃤.Kife :
Temu makes 60 billion a year. Does that mean what they sell is objectively high quality? Gordon Ramsey restaurants make 200 million a year. McDonalds makes 30 billion a year, does that mean McDonald’s is 150 times higher quality than Gordon Ramsay’s food?
2026-08-30 04:20:44
103
manio_e
manio_e :
popularity is not in any way correlative to quality 😭😭
2026-08-30 14:28:00
6
der_.vater
Der Vater :
How good that you cut out the part of the video where he explains that popularity doesn't equate to quality. Otherwise your argument completely falls apart.
2026-08-30 00:09:15
184
To see more videos from user @lthlnkso, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About