@econchrisclarke: The Western Water economy isn't capitalist. It's Central Planning with Fuedal Characteristics. Salt Lake Basin Alfalfa contribute 0.07% to Utah's GDP. In a region of 2.8M people, why should the 20k farmers get sympathy profits for producing a low value product? We need cap n trade water markets now! #economy #environment #economics #graph #desert
I hesitate to put my amateur foot in some sinkhole but isn't a significant part of the issue desertification?
2026-09-04 13:04:32
0
Jethro :
Alfalfa and hay are a low value crop. Nice. What are those crops used for?
2026-09-03 00:42:26
26
ginesthoi :
Refreshingly reasonable take.
2026-09-04 05:58:32
2
dynamocol :
The condo tower is probably the best use of the water lol
2026-09-04 13:01:21
1
Jono/Jonathan 🍉 :
The whole water rights system is terrible.
2026-09-04 11:06:34
0
Forthepraiseandglory :
Stop growing alfalfa for China. Problem solved. We waste water growing dry, compressed alfalfa bales to sell to China and we are draining the Colorado River to do it. Just stop doing that.
2026-09-03 15:28:26
10
williamedwards71 :
Capitalism would allocate water through an auction system. It would be more plentiful and there would never be shortages.
2026-09-04 10:28:58
1
Lateda :
Feeding livestock seems to be pretty important to society as a whole.
2026-09-03 18:39:47
3
Hunter Kozak :
My wife works for Utah Lake (a tributary of the Salt Lake) and she nodded vigorously throughout the video and thanks you for your services
2026-09-03 01:07:34
37
Chris :
Can we eminent domain water rights?
2026-09-03 18:09:59
1
Lanky Leopard :
No- environmentalism and government are to blame. With clean nuclear, good water stewardship, and pipelines the west could have infinite water
2026-09-03 15:27:43
3
Spaid Crystals :
Thank you!
2026-09-03 06:38:41
0
Ryder Bettencourt🇺🇸 :
I think this is a rare case where eminent domain would actually have a justifiable public good purpose. Those farms could developed for commercial and residential that produce far more value while the farmers would be compensated. It's far from perfect. I can imagine dozens of issues, but water really is a finite resource.
2026-09-03 01:56:46
6
Radical Sanity :
A lot of good points made here. However, there is a strong basis for protecting agriculture. If anything disrupts international trade, you need to be able to continue to grow enough food to feed everyone.
2026-09-03 19:58:03
1
impalajay65 :
Caring about this issue caused me to do an sizable amount of research, I found one thing that really blew me away. All of that “central planning“ that you are correct to criticize was based on an unobtainable constant. Rainfall, snowpack, River levels and Lake Mead, The Colorado and all sources were at a statistical Highpoint when they decided the numbers. They knew this at the time and for some reason here we are, mother nature living her best life with cycles of highs and lows no adjustments have been made!
2026-09-03 01:06:46
26
jwhat89 :
Very well done.
2026-09-03 00:30:19
10
Patrick H :
10 points for the Chinese characteristics joke
2026-09-03 02:37:57
11
⚔️🇺🇲 fluffy farmer🇺🇲❌⚔️ :
what about the imperialist?
2026-09-03 11:56:26
0
Quinnifer :
We export alfalfa so other countries can feed their livestock. Meaning we literally EXPORT OUR WATER. All these people whining about data centers are clueless about actual water use
2026-09-03 01:18:17
5
Matthew :
central planning feudal characteristics bad. unadulterated free-market capitalism good. from an "economist"
2026-09-03 13:10:29
0
sunnygoldenretrie :
Great video. Contrary to popular belief we don't "live under capitalism." We live under a mixed system with capitalist and "socialist" characteristics. Just like 99% of every country on earth
2026-09-03 16:01:57
0
Wadeant :
Water rights and usage in the West is a horrible entanglement of overlapping concerns and regulations. But it seems that you dismiss the importance of food security in this issue. Societies need food and shelter to survive. Almost everything else we consume is extra.
2026-09-03 02:54:36
2
Kirk Arnold :
They produce alfalfa and hay type products which in turn become beef, pork and sheep. Yeah, food. I’m kinda addicted to eating.
2026-09-03 20:07:58
0
Qu Kats :
ban export of hay and alfalfa outside the nation from the Colorado River basin a good chunk of it goes to the middle east.
2026-09-04 01:47:51
0
Father of Blues :
Excellent take
2026-09-03 17:22:39
4
To see more videos from user @econchrisclarke, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.