@senior.rdrr2: Interesting theory. Do you think Dutch really saw their spirits or is it just a visual effect? Would love to hear what others think about this idea.

bp0611013 :

whos muriel

whome? :

what if he looked at Arthur's ghost

Elliot 🔱 :

Or maybe he was just looking at John? 💔😭

Emil✝️ :

what if he looked at the ghost of everyone who died in the gang..

mr sigma :

what if Dutch see ghost Arthur

John Marston :

he saws Arthur's ghost

GTM :

i like the theory, but he was clearly just looking at john, love your videos tho man

🔥JOHN MARSTON🔥 :

can you give me the first image?

William Miller :

you forgot Lenny Arthur and Molly

BENJAMIN SMEDLEY :

And when would this take place

endme.02 :

And gloria

ČNT|MATEJA🇷🇸 :

what he see

𝖘𝖎𝖒𝖔𝖓𝖊 :

who?

Pedro Escamilla :

what if he saw Hosea and Arthur

Bloodhound :

Not even a theory

¿ :

i think he was looking at arthur morgan and hosea Matthews

I AM BATMAN :

what if he looked at Arthur behind John then looked over and saw the rest of the gang including Micah

hadi ރ :

why does john look like that

R9phenomeno✪ :

Endri 🇦🇱 :

what if he looked the protagonist from rdr3?

jakyrnharrison :

wouldn't make any sense

gerald_demarcus_cousins :

By the way rockstar didn’t even know who Arthur was because he wasn’t in their mind

{[\Black_Death/]} :

Maybe Arthur and Hosea

. :

The likes are crazy

Breacc Glas :

What if he was just fucking looking at John?