@drtoddphillips: Lindsay Clancy never claimed God told her to kill her children. I’m changing that one detail to ask a moral question. If you believe 1 Samuel 15 accurately records God commanding Saul to kill children and infants, then can you still say killing babies is always morally wrong? Or is the actual position that killing babies is wrong unless God commands it? That distinction matters. #lindsayclancy #deconstruction #agnostic #exvangelical #faithjourney

Jesse Norwalt :

God can kill whoever he wants whenever he wants he created them. The harder question is why does he use humans to do this

Paul :

so me in the new testament where God says kill your kids??

soccermillie :

Where did you get your sense of morality? If there wasn’t a god?

Chris Stedman :

My brother would be like, is that in the Old Testament? They love to pick and choose Gods word

Mariano :

Of course, there's that other reply: "but that was in the Old Testament". Then they go on to say that it's not that God was crueler then, but that people were more primitive and he had to adjust his teachings to that... Which makes no sense at all.

momenntum :

perhaps it's true that when 2nd Samuel was written, whomever claimed that God ordered the killing of babies was mistaken. perhaps God never said that or ordered that but it was still interpreted incorrectly from man...

Ernst :

logical impossibility. thats like saying, if killing your children is good. would it be good?

OnlyShee :

they all say the same thing... that wasn't God because he wouldn't do that.

Dr. Cailey | Pelvic Floor PT :

Omg thank you I’ve been saying this

Mikey Jones 🧢 :

Have you not noticed these “commands” aren’t trying to mimic God. They mimic demons. We all have them, some just let them out.

nadja_b :

Believers would say that since God told them, it was legit.

Elusive :

if God were real - his communication skills would be amazing. There wouldn't be any doubt about his very existence or what he wants.

Big Maur :

This makes me scared of super religious people because they think a random thought in their head and say “God told me……” what if God tells them something to harm me or my family 😩

THE_GHOSTFACE! :

read the story of Judas god told him kill his kid he was stopped and it turned out it was the devil ....if the devil in you does this then it's still you he just tempted you

jerrydavido :

how would she know or not know it's god voice

LESTAT NOEL THORREAUX :

jenniferblackbur63 :

well they think its fine in the Bible killing all first born sons like wtf

Jairrrito :

How they wrote the bible

gary :

Shaking my head. Believer's can't have it both ways !!

man :

If there’s enough authority behind a command, it’s always right.

Bubugirl 🌺✨ :

It wasn’t God it was someone with a God complex though 😜

Barry :

When you find out, your heart is more kind than your doctrine or your theology or your God just maybe your heart is correct!

cantubantu 🇨🇦 :

Lindsay Abraham 😩

. :

U watch Alex o Connor?

Freda🌛🌑🌜Khan :

They would say God only told prophets and there are no prophets today!