dowx :
In an ideal world, everyone who joins the civil service would be driven purely by passion and patriotism, not compensation. But we don’t live in that world. In reality, top talent in Singapore and the world naturally gravitates toward roles that offer the greatest professional and financial upside. That’s simply how incentives work.
If we genuinely want capable people to even consider public service, compensation has to be part of the equation. The talent pool in singapore is already small. Removing financial competitiveness shrinks it further. Passion is important, but passion alone doesn’t produce good policy. Good intentions don’t automatically translate into good governance. Running a country requires competence, judgement, and strategic thinking and attracting such individuals means recognising that pay is not a luxury, but a practical necessity. Wanting leaders who serve for the right reasons is admirable. But pretending that passion alone will attract and retain the people capable of steering a nation is idealistic, not realistic.
We want the top 0.01% of people to run the country. The ones with the judgement, competence, and strategic ability to steer a nation. But if that’s truly the standard, then the compensation must realistically reflect the calibre we’re asking for. Expecting world‑class talent to take on heavier workload, constant public scrutiny, and loss of privacy while earning far less is not noble, it’s idealistic. In a small country like Singapore, the talent pool is already limited. If we want the very best to even consider public service, then competitive pay isn’t a luxury, it’s simply an accurate representation of the level of responsibility we expect them to shoulder.
And to add on, using Mamdani as an example doesn’t actually strengthen the argument. The United States has a deeply fragmented and often inefficient governance system, with political gridlock, entrenched partisanship, and inconsistent policy execution. In that environment, someone like Mamdani is a gem in the rough, a rare outlier who rises despite the system, not because of it.
2026-09-18 16:20:12