ugh i'm so mad they gave adam essentially no background. he loved and was yearning for olive for years 😭 and he had a long time best friend who was huge in revealing more about adam and his history and was a catalyst in olive and adam's relationship 😭
2026-09-25 19:45:39
3375
ESC :
Yeah he had more of like a brilliant autistic vibe. Someone without social skills than an evil vibe.
2026-09-25 21:06:42
1623
..ginii :
We get his “why he’s a villain” in the book because of his best friend Holden WHO THEY TOOK OUR OF THE MOVIE😭. And they didn’t give us a moment he is in love with her because HE HAS BEEN IN LOVE WITH HER FOR 3 YEARS WHICH THEY ALSO TOOK OUT. Also she is a phd student trying to get a doctorate. He is a post doc teaching the phd students. He’s not on her dissertation board but he is on Malcolm’s who is her best friend. Malcolm is also on Adam’s research team which is how he could fire him.
2026-09-25 19:51:26
663
Kae Mcc :
honorable mention for most insane line being "you're edible olive" SCREAMED NOT IN A GOOD WAY but I loved this movie down idc
2026-09-25 23:28:42
115
Jess Rodgers :
oh don’t worry as a real-life phd student their whole relationship is very much a gray area. the weirdest part for me is the other faculty seem fine with it?!
2026-09-25 19:46:32
1282
Tinkerbell✨ :
You need to watch a different world
2026-09-25 20:26:18
29
Breanna Roethler :
Could even have a small montage of him seeing her through the years and him having a crush or something
2026-09-25 21:02:34
698
Sierra Spencer Books :
As a professor, I also did not understand the academic hierarchy in this movie. Fwiw, the hierarchy is accurate to academia in the book. They don’t really interact at all there because he does a different niche of biology than Olive.
2026-09-25 19:46:17
179
Chloe Ross :
This is the most accurate review. Is it a great movie? No. Will I watch it again? 100%. Is it because of the male main character? No. Is it because of Lili Reinhart? 100000000% yes
2026-09-25 20:20:10
403
Emily :
Unfortunately it was not a good book to movie adaptation but it was a good movie
2026-10-02 23:38:48
0
cleeks :
steminist is cringe but its allllll Ali Hazelwood, that was a note to the Hazelwood universe:)
2026-09-25 20:12:31
33
sappien :
The thing is, in both the book & fanfic, Adam is just a normal guy!! He has a reputation for being very harsh, strict, and he’s got high expectations for his students, but he’s not “Dr Evil”. He just cares a lot about his work & he’s kinda quiet? They made him into such a bad caricature or parody of Kylo Ren.
2026-09-25 23:55:24
90
cgq2012 :
Adam Carlson is perfect don’t piss me off
2026-09-26 00:29:16
37
Amanda :
Catch me reading the book now cause I guess the entire 3rd act is much better in the book. Also hi I need Lili in more things
2026-09-26 04:22:57
30
Nissii :
I wish it was a series instead of a movie, as a lover of the book and everything Ali Hazelwood it was cute but not nearly enough
2026-09-25 23:09:24
90
carey :
He’s not a villain at all, and I’m so bummed that the movie left out his backstory so that you think that. He is an imperfect man with a lot of history trying to be the best man he can be while ensuring that every student he oversees is the very best they can be. He has loved Olive for years, and is a huge champion of her work.
2026-09-26 00:23:50
17
Haley🍉 :
I just thought his character was meant to be very blunt and, while not unaware that people thought he was awful, he believed that the truth(even in its harshest form) was better than softening things or giving chances where they may not be earned. He wasn’t wrong about any of his firing decisions; the roommate hated that field and was objectively bad at his position, Mountain Dew is going to reoffend, dead dog girl probably did do much better and is better off(rip doggy) because of his criticism. He isn’t malicious or cruel like his professor , he’s just brutally honest and socially awkward. Because of his horrible experience, he probably just thinks “these people have no idea what ‘evil’ looks like” and so he doesn’t give much thought to it. Idk I thought it was actually kind of interesting
2026-09-26 00:26:56
5
Bookmark :
As someone who did read the book (more than once) they butchered the ending !!! but I will be watching it again bc I love lili
2026-09-25 20:25:09
30
JíbaraEnTexas :
The casting was perfect
The screen writing could have been better but for some reason they decided to change some stuff & completely cut out others
2026-09-25 22:36:40
13
brookie :
they got rid of all of his personality. adam carlsen i mourn you
2026-09-25 20:22:58
7
ms.kennann :
I read the book after I watched it and got way more insight into Adam and the ending/ sexual harassment thing was handled way better. Lili is perfect!
2026-09-25 21:02:54
10
gabs :
i love the book but I did not like adam in the movie😭 also everyone is talking about how funny it is that tom bateman is playing adam, but I think it’s a little odd bc he inspired tom benton, the character who sexually harassed olive, aka his wife
2026-09-25 19:42:27
51
jenny :
The book was better (always is lol)
2026-09-25 19:40:13
10
juliana :
let me start out with i started “skeptical” (hype) and was not liking the male lead until i suddenly gave into the movie by 27 minutes and i was giggling and squealing and i didn’t even like him
2026-09-25 20:41:13
5
annalisa :
you NEED to watch lili in hal&harper
2026-09-25 19:37:23
13
To see more videos from user @jcubedhax, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.