@recycldstardust: Hear me out, indigenous peoples day shouldn’t be on “Columbus” day. Year after year, I hear about so much animosity and anger towards indigenous people who are trying to take over a day that many Italian Americans believe belongs to them. As a Native American indigenous person myself I do believe that we do need to have an indigenous peoples day that celebrate the resiliency of native people despite Columbus’s efforts, but trying to erase a day that was given to Italian immigrants because of the violence, discrimination, and prejudice that they had to endure really doesn’t help anybody. I also don’t think our struggles were in any way equal, but nonetheless as human beings we should be in this together. We should uplift each other. That includes not celebrating a historical figure that kicked off the genocide of many native nations. We can celebrate Italian American culture in more positive ways with better more honorable figures. I do think there needs to be an indigenous peoples day on its own separate day that doesn’t take away from that Italian American heritage so that we can both have the proper time and the proper space to be respected so we can more easily support each other rather than sharing a day where we oppose each other. #i#IndigenousTikToki#indigenouspeoplesdayn#nativetiktok

Recycledstardust
Recycledstardust
Open In TikTok:
Region: US
Monday 12 October 2026 20:51:26 GMT
4122
588
13
29

Music

Download

Comments

grace.west41
Grace West :
I love this take. You are not trying to demonize a whole people group. But saying why are we celebrating an evil man. I fully agree with you.
2026-10-13 15:51:34
1
fourlittlebees
Fourlittle Bees :
I’m Italian-American. I am fine with replacing Columbus Day exactly on the day. It’s a celebration of a non-Italian villain who enslaved Native Americans originally granted to try to appease Italian-Americans after a mass lynching. The conflation with Italian-American pride exists because so few Italian-Americans understand our history in this country. The 1891 Lynching took place March 14, 1891. Move our day to THAT day so more Italian-Americans can actually learn something.
2026-10-13 01:09:29
14
1eyedmanchild
1 Eyed Man Child :
Mohawk? thats a Canadian tribe
2026-10-13 03:59:47
0
julzb26
Juls26🇲🇽🖤🤎💙 :
I agree with you especially about historical honesty, and if we are able to have days where we can learn and celebrate our cultures, others also can learn most importantly about our cultures and our histories together!
2026-10-12 21:05:32
15
grandmabo_33
user7324290438912 :
Amen sister
2026-10-13 01:08:54
0
thetaylorknight
Taylor Knight :
I’m part Italian on my father’s side
2026-10-12 22:01:44
1
kellyjj19
kellyjj19 :
You’re right. This is probably an unpopular opinion.
2026-10-12 21:05:02
2
hybridv3
Tired :
They are drastically different and I believe you know that. The Italians came here by choice and suffered. What a few decades if that not being seen as white?? They did not suffer on the same level as the Native Americans. Are you kidding me? The moment they were accepted as white they turned their backs on every other minority group that they stood with or were in solidarity with. Italians and Native Americans are not the same in their suffering. That’s a massively uninformed take 😒
2026-10-12 23:30:46
3
whatsmykidsnameagain
whatsmykidsnameagain :
Ok but Christopher Columbus was a horrible person and the only reason why we have Christopher Columbus Day is because they lynched Italians in Louisiana and it was quick thinking of that times administration to make sure the mob didn’t come after them… As an Italian nobody likes Christopher Columbus and we’re still salty about the lynchings. I personally don’t celebrate my Italian heritage on Columbus Day …. I do it on the feast of Saint Anthony….but to each their own. Should ABSOLUTELY be Indigenous People Day!! (also low-key Italians are considered “white”now. We don’t have a box to check on our intake forms)
2026-10-13 03:29:06
1
bluebuffspanielgirl
bluebuffspanielgirl :
As a African American I love both Native Americans and Italian Americans
2026-10-13 00:37:14
1
To see more videos from user @recycldstardust, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About