@the.aussie.gege: Was the Manchu Qing dynasty a Manchu or Chinese dynasty? #china #chinese #qing #manchu #History

Aussie Double Ge
Aussie Double Ge
Open In TikTok:
Region: AU
Thursday 22 October 2026 09:16:47 GMT
5918
234
70
12

Music

Download

Comments

turbo_lynn
turbo :
manchus are chinese and qing dynasty is a chinese dynasty, they’re just not han
2026-10-22 09:23:57
26
sskguo
Sskguo :
Qing was orthodox imperial Chinese dynasty, through the Mandate of Heaven. 90 percent of Qing armies were Han Chinese military forces. The Qing founder Manchu tribes were former Ming dynasty Chinese subjects, having served under the Han Chinese imperial army for generations before rebelling. Manchuria was under Ming China rule. The vast majority of the Qing Eight Banner military were made up of Han Chinese Banner warriors. The Ming dynasty collapsed from a Han Chinese civil war, not conquered by the Qing. And the Qing succeeded the Ming as the next ruling imperial Chinese dynasty, governed under Zhonghua Han Chinese imperial statecraft, institutions, and governmental political system. The Qing Chinese government and military throughout its 268-year reign were filled with overwhelming majority Han Chinese officials, generals, and soldiers. Territorial expansion into Tibet and Xinjiang relied heavily on the vast majority of Han Chinese military forces' participation. During Qing China, Tibet was recaptured by Han Chinese general Yue Zhongqi with predominantly Han Chinese military forces; likewise, Xinjiang was recaptured by Han Chinese general Zuo Zongtang with overwhelming Han Chinese military forces. Taiwan was conquered by Han Chinese Admiral Shi Lang, with an army and navy made up of overwhelmingly Han Chinese military forces. The Qing dynasty ruled its entire realm, including Tibet, Xinjiang, Outer Mongolia, and Taiwan, as a unified Zhongguo China polity and imperial Chinese state. When signing international treaties with foreign nations, Qing explicitly identified itself as Zhongguo China, and with the United States of America, it identified itself as the Chinese Great Qing State and, in Chinese Hanzi, Zhonghua Da Qing Guo, to describe its entire realm. Most Qing Chinese emperors were of Manchu and Han ancestry mixed from Kangxi onward; Kangxi's mother was from the Han Chinese Banner family. The last Qing Chinese emperor Puyi became an ordinary Chinese citizen. The Qing dynasty was the last imperial Chinese empire, succeeded by the Republic of China in 1912. Manchus are Chinese minority ethnic group, heavily Hanified and Sinicized.
2026-10-22 23:04:47
13
laisiert
Eswareinmal :
Qing is one of the most debatable dynasties in Chinese history. I’ve seen so many western scholars trying to delegitimize the Qing as a true Chinese dynasty way too often, just to further tarnish the current rule of the CPC. The concept of multi ethnic state? Not my words, but apparently fabricated to get them more power. If you look closely into western history, they also just made up things along the way to legitimize themselves, so they are not alone at all. 🤷‍♀️
2026-10-22 09:45:09
7
monoton729
Koyo :
Founder of Qing was originally a subject of Ming before revolt
2026-10-25 19:11:30
3
washr555
Bruno :
If they weren't foreign there would have been no need for them to adapt to chinese customs or force manchu traditions on the Han population. The Qing looked at past foreign dynasties failures and took deliberate steps to legitimize their rule.
2026-10-22 12:53:34
7
ravic4682
awesome :
if they are not colonialist from the west then they are chinese[Big LOL][Big LOL]
2026-10-22 15:23:16
1
summerbreezenblossoms
summerbreeze :
The Qing adopted and considered themselves the inheriter of the previous dynasty so yes, they absorbed, embedded and assimilated themselves into the Chinese hemisphere.
2026-10-22 14:10:13
3
yeou659
Yeou :
They were Manchurians who today are one of the 56 minorities of China. They were Chinese but not Hans.
2026-10-22 14:14:45
4
taji_aziz94
ꦠꦗꦶꦄꦩ꦳ꦶꦗ꦳꧀ (aziz) :
According to historical records I have read, during a land dispute in which territory belonging to the Hmong people was seized by the Han ethnic group, the Qing Dynasty sided with the Han. Consequently, the Hmong—who refused to accept this outcome—were driven from their lands, became fugitives, and were forced to flee to Southeast Asia in search of refuge. They also refused to style their hair in the *queue* (the long, braided ponytail mandated by the Qing Dynasty), a practice to which all Han people conformed.
2026-11-04 19:53:20
0
sjj561
SJ :
There are so many different interpretations in these comments.
2026-10-26 11:56:17
1
di_shimperor
shimperor :
They had very different views to normal Chinese people, including expansive imperialism.
2026-10-22 12:56:45
3
life_adefenderofchina
a defender of china :
So its like the Hyksos in Egypt?
2026-10-22 11:50:26
1
nerguiiuu
Elstei :
Da Chin means Warrior in Mongolian and Manchus uses to call themselves like that
2026-11-09 16:21:46
0
catemoji14736251
FriesAndKetchup :
2026-10-22 14:35:39
0
sskguo
Sskguo :
Intermarriage between Manchu and Han was allowed within the Banner system. Most Qing Chinese emperors from Kangxi onward until Puyi had Manchu and Han ancestry. Kangxi's mother was from the Han Chinese Banner family. Only Bannermen were not allowed to marry into civilian populations, regardless of ethnic group, in order to preserve Banner family traditions. Civilian populations not in the Banner system, regardless of ethnic group, including Han and Manchu, could intermarry. The Qing Banner system had three branches: Han, Manchu, and Mongol. Han Chinese Banner warriors were the largest at 76 percent, Manchu 16 percent, and Mongol 8 percent. All Bannermen, regardless of ethnic group, could intermarry. Besides the Eight Banners, which made up only 20 percent of the entire Qing Chinese military, the remaining main bulk 80 percent consisted of the Han Chinese Green Standard Army, which was the main regular standing army of Qing China.
2026-10-23 08:50:42
1
sskguo
Sskguo :
Both Yuan and Qing were imperial Chinese dynasties. Although the Yuan Chinese emperors were ethnic Mongols and the Qing Chinese emperors were ethnic Manchus mixed with Han, both dynasties still operated and governed under the Sinitic Han Chinese imperial statecraft and Zhonghua political tradition framework as imperial China Zhongguo. Both Yuan and Qing imperial Chinese governments and militaries were still overwhelmingly majority, at least 90 percent, composed of Han Chinese officials, generals, and soldiers throughout their reigns.
2026-10-22 23:03:34
3
shengwang509
shengwang509 :
不是满汉不通婚,而是旗民不通婚,满人如果不是旗人也不能结婚,汉旗和满旗是可以结婚的。
2026-10-22 13:17:29
1
rong60320
Rong :
The Mongol Yuan were also a Chinese dynasty. The prevailing Han Confucian culture and bureaucracy assimilates all ethnicities. This is the strength of the Middle Kingdom. This is the greatest of Chinese soft power. The wisdom of a continuous 5,000 year old living civilization is our world’s future.,
2026-10-22 13:06:32
5
wei.rao6
wei rao :
不算!我们汉族人不认! 满清是殖民政权!
2026-10-22 12:14:19
4
shihsvcurqp
Goss :
I know a few Manchus. Don’t tell them they are not Chinese. They aren’t Han, but they call themselves Chinese.
2026-10-23 03:45:33
2
split.g7
Split.G :
中国对于正统性的判断依据是文化和制度,而不是人种 满清的统治者里,奴儿哈赤当然不算中国人,因为他采取的是满族的文化,而顺治开始就算中国人了,因为他除了血统以外,和一个汉族人其实没有任何差别 同样的道理,成吉思汗的蒙古帝国不能算中国的朝代,但忽必烈的元朝是正统的中国朝代 换到欧洲也一样,你难道能说征服者威廉不是英国人,所以现在的英国是殖民地吗?
2026-10-22 17:44:25
4
therebbtherebbb
paruan :
算现代中国王朝,而不是华夏王朝、中原王朝。
2026-10-23 06:47:45
2
lisatao
Lisa Tao :
They weren’t Han, but they were Chinese.
2026-10-22 15:56:06
3
mynameis_shakezilla
shakezilla :
hong taiji changed their ethnic identity from jurchen to manchu to distance themselves from their ancestors that formed the hated jin dynasty, so as to make their rule over china less problematic
2026-10-22 18:35:53
1
supers1224
Supers122 :
😁
2026-10-22 13:06:42
2
To see more videos from user @the.aussie.gege, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About