@mariannanutt: Just thinking (this is a what if dont take me seriously) #Arthurmorgan #Rdr2 #rdr2headcanons

Player Sam I am :

What if Isaac, since he was 4, hid somewhere, like attic or bushes because he was playing outside. The killers didn’t find him, then he ran away. Grew up and didn’t want to go meet Arthur because he either forgot about Arthur or he never forgave him for not being there when his mother died. Then that’s how Jason Duval could be related to Arthur

African Baby :

Someone said that Arthur’s son ran away, there was 2 graves that mf got killed bro

X23 :

most horrific theory ive heard but idkw but it sounds so on brand

Bread✝️ :

this is something he WOULD do too

Treygasyy :

Type shit Walter would do to Jesse when he found someone he loved

Deniz :

He‘d pull some shi* like this during RDR1 but I don‘t think he was that bad at the start of RDR2

Siilipoiss :

Always thought it was odd some random robbers would bother to dig a grave for two people they don't know. But Dutch having them offed and buried makes a weird amount of sense

Kat :

and what if I told you he also never told Hosea either bc he would have flipped his SHIT 😭

⚜️ :

Ngl It’s much more impactful for Eliza and Isaac to have did to a random criminal, it’s the kind of senseless and cruel violence that Dutch built the gang’s moral code on avoiding/avenging. They used to stand out because of it, Dutch resorting to that same senseless violence later in the game was a big factor to what alienated him to Arthur. It also doesn’t really make sense with his character at the time😭 plus Arthur back then would have never even considered leaving the gang and having a normal life, next yall are gonna say Dutch had Bessie killed cause Hosea actually did leave the gang to be with her for a while

Ajay :

I can just imagine Dutch saying "Son, I had to do what was necessary.....TO KEEP THIS GROUP TOGETHER! Trust in me a little longer...BELIEVE IN MEEEE!"

Oliver :

one theory I thought about is that maybe Eliza wanted to escape the dangers that Arthur may have accidentally put her through and she killed the two robbers and fled the area. And maybe they could add a game about Issac if the theory works, And show Issac become a gunslinger.

JH :

You are EVIL

Hailey Prosser :

I can 100% believe it

𝔐𝔦𝔰𝔞𝔢𝔩 ཐི༏ཋྀ ــــــﮩ٨ـ :

Everyday I spend in this fandom is another day in hell I see

addie :

i hate that i love this

a_red :

complete mischaracterization of Dutch, not something he'd ever do - he's an incredibly complex character and worth genuinely understanding.

PelicanL0rd :

This was pre crazy Dutch thoug

Daddy4Monster :

That's actually a really good one I may think about sharing that to other fans sometime.

Silas Baker :

bessie :

maybe he paid 10 bucks

The_Don :

on your fûcking LEFT—💔😭

Dutch :

I did no such thing, must've been the wind..

lalo :

Finally not a “uncle might be red harlow” theory

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 Justine‽‽‽ :

I get that Dutch has done some messed up things but I just dont see him doing something this drastic and evil. in his sound mind too.

Samael🇬🇧🇳🇬 :

I won’t be surprised if