aisha khan :
I am so sad. They really shouldn’t have overridden Allah’s words and the principles of justice and mercy in Islam.
What makes this even more heartbreaking is that they were very young. Why was the first response not to give them a chance to learn from their mistakes, repent to Allah, and change their lives? Why weren’t they given a lesser punishment, such as imprisonment, if the authorities believed a punishment was necessary? Why was taking their lives considered the answer? Why weren’t they given the opportunity to seek forgiveness from Allah and become better people?
If the authorities believed that these young people had committed an offence, why couldn’t they have been deported to their home country, if legally possible, or given a proportionate punishment that did not involve taking their lives? There were surely other ways to respond to this situation without resorting to the death penalty.
The Quran does not state anywhere that if someone commits zina inside a mosque, they should automatically be given the death penalty. The Quran specifies a punishment for zina, and it does not prescribe execution simply because the act takes place inside a mosque.
Even if the two young people were not married to each other, that does not mean they should automatically face the death penalty. The Quran does not prescribe capital punishment for zina simply because the individuals are unmarried, nor does it establish a separate death penalty based on the location of the act. If the Saudi authorities justified this punishment under their national law or a particular interpretation of Islamic jurisprudence, then the relevant legal grounds should be explained clearly and transparently.
Why was there no clear public warning explaining the consequences of such behaviour? If the authorities believed that behaving indecently in a mosque could lead to the death penalty, why weren’t clear notices and public announcements displayed throughout the country, explaining the law and its consequences? People should be informed of the rules they are expected to follow. If the authorities believed such conduct warranted a serious punishment, they should have made the law and its conse
2026-10-26 18:10:23