@abulaythclips: #muslim #Islam #abulayth #muftiabulayth

West Yorkshire Tissue Company :

give us an example of where it contradicts the Quran....

Ahmed Karzoun :

Thank you. I am sick and tired of people quoting hadiths that contradict the Quran.

AshSmash :

firabri says he learned all the hadith from bukhari going through his collection twice. 3 other alleged bukhari students muslim, tirimzi and ibn maja wrote their own books.

taftazani :

prof. jonathan ac brown wrote a good refutation of this

hab ib :

Ferrari? does he make cars ?

The Moors :

Al-Firabri was known to hadith scholars during his lifetime. Al-Mustamli, Ibn Hammuyah, Abu Zayd al-Marwazi and al-Kushmihani travelled to hear Sahih al-Bukhari from him. Al-Sam‘ani records: “People travelled to him and transmitted this book from him.” That establishes his recognition.

Nobody :

Sahih al Bukhari has reached such a high level of fame that it doesn’t even need a chain of transmission, let alone looking at it. Ibn Hajar says in his book al Nakt 1/271: ‘The book that is well-known, which is so famous that it requires no consideration of the isnad from us back to its author: like the Sunan of al Nasa’i, for example. It does not need, in order to establish its attribution to al Nasa’i, any consideration of the condition of the men in the chain of transmission from us back to its author’

إبراهيم :

@I’m

FazLhaq M :

What a great job you doing my Allah bless you [Heartwarming][Heartwarming][Heartwarming][Heartwarming][Heartwarming]

ZackIsBack :

So interesting

Islamic daily contents :

having different editions don't make it bad

jay :

mashallah awsome point 👌👌👌

Dsplug :

West Yorkshire Tissue Company :

Several major hadith scholars regarded him as trustworthy (thiqa). Among them: Imam al-Dhahabi. Imam al-Baji. Imam Ibn Rushayd. Imam al-Safadi.

Islamic daily contents :

this guy is saying something man made

Ashir :

mashallah our sheikh ul Islam may Allah bless him

user98123690 :

Has this been challenged ever? Would like to see what others think of this, very interesting

IJ :

I love deviants and hadith rejectors alike love to place all their focus on Bukhari. Little do they know that with or without Bukhari those same hadith will always exist.

jryivfjhguj :

al farabri was talking about tabwib the tiles of hadiths not the hadiths also he finished copying sahih bukhari he had the full copy of the original one and he was known as a truthful guy what your saying is the same disbeliever arguments

Jumah Imran Jumah :

Yeah the latest trend now has become ḥadith bashing.. But my problem with some of the ḥadith bashing dudes is a complete lack of adab-al ikhtilaf when doing their ḥadith bashing.. you can do your bashing as much as you like, but please do it with adab and taqwa.. for taq'wa is the supreme benchmark of human nobility. (inna akramakum 'inda llahi atqaakum) •• Linguistically, taqwa is rooted in self-restraint and guarding oneself against divine displeasure, it represents an acute, constant inner consciousness of God's presence and one's ultimate accountability before Him. •• Taqwa internalizes and universalizes ethics: true honor (karamah) never stems from bloodline, tribal clout, or arrogant self-assertion (jahl), but from surrendering the ego to God's moral boundaries! Issues involving ḥadith are very sensitive and very serious matters, so we have to handle them with all the sensitivity we can muster for this involves people's faith/iman and akhera! We cannot discuss or talk about ḥadith as if it was some kind of football match between Barca and Man United!

Archミギ :

@Kuzon @tulli

rola :

The Umayyads and Abbasids played significant roles in the development, compilation, and politicization of hadith, which directly relates to the question of hadith contradicting the Quran. The Umayyad Dynasty (661–750 CE) • Political Legitimacy: The Umayyads transformed the caliphate into a hereditary monarchy and actively promoted religious narratives to legitimize their rule. • Fabrication of Hadith: Reports suggest they sponsored or tolerated the circulation of fabricated hadith to praise their lineage and justify their policies. • Propaganda Tools: They used hadith as political weapons, such as cursing Ali from pulpits for 60 years to marginalize his role. The Abbasid Dynasty (750–1258 CE) • Inheritance of Propaganda: When they overthrew the Umayyads, they inherited many of these fabricated hadiths rather than dismantling them. • Selective Praise: They replaced the cursing of Ali with selective praise to appropriate his legacy while protecting their own power. • Systematic Compilation: During their era, scholars began systematically collecting and compiling hadith into books, with rulers urging them to collect traditions that supported their authority. Impact on Hadith-Quran Contradictions • Alignment with State Creed: The compilers of hadith worked under an unspoken constraint: they focused on collecting traditions that fortified orthodoxy and aligned with the state's political narrative. • Content vs. Chain: Critics argue that while scholars were meticulous about verifying the isnad (chain of transmission), they sometimes ignored the matn (content), allowing contradictions with the Quran to persist.

FazLhaq M :

[Perfect score][Perfect score][Perfect score][Perfect score][Perfect score][Perfect score][Perfect score][Perfect score][Perfect score][Perfect score][Perfect score]

❤️‍🩹beauty💞Dutch❤️ :

but we know 99% hadiths contradict the Quran. marry a child . women can't pray on period or have to ask permission or have to obey her husband thats her deen according hadiths then most women are in helfire or women have half brain it's all Sahi ....but not from the Quran... and I can go on and on what about all the rules haram halal in the Hadiths not from the Quran also 0 autorty from Allah Prohet had 0 autorty from Allah black Kaba kissing walking around not from the Quran or there Ramada is not from the Quran so 99% contradict the Quran from Hadiths