@allin: David Friedberg: France’s Crisis Is a Warning for America “France is a bellwether for the West. So take a look at this chart. This chart is a measure of public spending as a percent of GDP. And you can see the comparison of France's public spending as a percent of GDP to the peak public spending as a percent of GDP of major communist nations. Chamath: “So do you think France is a communist state? They spend like it.” Jason: “Well, it's certainly been a socialist state, right?” Chamath: “Is it working?” Friedberg: “That's my point. And I think this is such a prescient lesson for the West to look at. We all think that there's some political problem with Macron or whoever it was. The more the government spends, the worse the conditions get for its people, not the opposite, and then the people riot and revolt. Take a guess where the US is today. US public spending is roughly 36% of GDP. France today is operating its national government spending deficit is 5.4% of GDP. The US is actually 6.2% of GDP. France is, I think, probably the first to go because they're only growing their economy at half a percent while the US is growing at 2.3%. So we're still kind of hanging on because we have some degree of economic growth that's allowing us to kind of hold things together. But I would argue that we are facing the same sort of fiscal cliff which leads to this extraordinary social unrest as France. All the economic measures are aligned, we're at the same rate, we're at the same set of problems, and we're starting to see the cracks in the system. There's probably a multi-year solution.”
the all-in podcast
Region: US
Tuesday 27 October 2026 20:09:59 GMT
Music
Download
Comments
Dick HammerBush :
Billionaires in the United States need to start stepping in right now. Everywhere is expensive at the moment.
2026-10-27 20:29:55
5
Charo's guitar :
everything is never enough.
2026-10-27 23:28:39
12
Dr Grossman :
France is way too socialist of course, but chart is misleading. Real nr for communist states was close to 100%, counting also state controlled enterprises...
2026-10-27 20:36:52
0
cadadiasma :
argentina os that exacto case. with socialist policies before milei poverty rose to 60%, now ground 30%
2026-10-31 11:26:59
0
11721£ :
Bottom Line the working class (if which I am) is overweened and given too much which then in the same breathe gets taken away by local, state and federal taxes. In other words the government gives nothing it takes!
2026-10-27 21:33:51
0
jbt5892 :
Or we focus on holding those who spend the money accountable and see its put to better use instead of wasted. That's why I don't want to see any tax dollars raised instead I want them cut until they stop wasting it.
2026-10-27 22:56:35
0
mwandokamau :
they refused to invest in their colonies .... enjoy 😍
2026-10-28 11:23:07
0
dougvladick :
For some reason socialist think we must take the money from the greedy millionaires and the government needs it because they would never be greedy or corrupt. But it’s actually the other way around.
2026-10-27 21:56:15
2
gluckstein :
couldnt possible be high soending because of capitslists lobbying governments for extraordinarily expensive contracts to enrich themselves and their friends. just because a government is spending money, doesnt make it socialist, if its enriching huge private corporations and billionaires. this is just another iteration of corruption due to end stage capitalism
2026-10-27 20:30:30
0
Don Kruuz :
What is wrong with China?
2026-10-27 21:30:33
0
Marty Heiser :
vote REPUBLICAN
2026-10-28 03:28:17
0
S…12345678910 :
America is also having unrest with capitalism sooooo. France is also capitalist but I’ll use your fake definitions
2026-10-27 21:47:25
0
Nunya bidnizz :
Folks - these people are coming for everything you have. Everything bad happening across the globe is because of their insatiable greed.
2026-11-08 05:45:53
0
11721£ :
Billionaires need to step up and help destroy this ruling class we have…. Elon can’t do all things by himself
2026-10-27 21:34:40
0
user74739961858618 :
This is such a dumb simplistic take, what about Denmark and Norway, New Zealand, Australia etc.
2026-10-28 06:29:23
8
Biscotti R Jones :
bellwether of going broke?.
2026-10-28 02:38:02
0
fuqlibitards99 :
Governments can’t do ANYTHING efficiently! The socialism works fallacy is INSANE
2026-10-27 22:17:40
3
To see more videos from user @allin, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.