And what if I said I agreed with every single one of her scores
2026-10-28 02:11:20
4430
Lexi Crommett :
I’m honestly here for Shirley and her comments because she does it respectfully
2026-10-28 01:35:34
9104
pradaprosciutto :
The overscoring is so egregious, but the audience also has to stop booing at every single critique. It’s so annoying
2026-10-28 02:29:52
1140
Kaitlyn Shutes :
I want Shirley to be a permanent judge so bad!!
2026-10-28 01:33:06
1336
Rat :
sure but a 4 was unnecessary
2026-10-28 02:56:02
208
Speedy :
They’re too afraid to bring out the low paddles. I’m happy to see someone who judges just the dance. Not the metrics of social media
2026-10-28 01:24:03
4360
insomniac830 :
I love Julia but I didn’t feel like she was dancing at all. I hate to see the 4 but I totally get it. Now Harry…. He should have been 9’s idk what anyone says he didn’t move around much either. I think all the other contemporary dances were just so much more
2026-10-28 02:53:05
26
Teresa Callahan :
If she would’ve been tough on everybody I would agree but I don’t think she fairly scored everyone. How did Tyler get better than Julia and Tatyana? I know they did different dances but that was insane
2026-10-28 02:46:17
52
Liv Duncan :
Petition for everyone to get the same genre or dance style every week!!!!!! The ballroom scores vs the jazz and contemporary was egregious
2026-10-28 03:27:57
5
francescaandherpups :
Shirley was polite kind and firm in her standards. That’s how we should ALL be in life!
2026-10-28 05:14:23
1
Rio Miller :
I appreciated the low scores to start but then even she raised it up and screwed the earlier performers. Julia was not that much below Tyler… come on.
2026-10-28 02:42:27
225
👐hit :
I think Shirley is just as tough as Len score wise but a little more gentle about her verbal criticisms so tbh she’s perfect for a Disney+ show, they need to keep her on!
2026-10-28 02:01:56
131
sb10 :
Like WHY are we starting episode 1 with 7s????
2026-10-28 02:48:45
16
mangetout :
I loved it tbh give me REAL SCORES
2026-10-28 02:24:03
1
amanda :
i miss len
2026-10-28 04:57:51
1
Jacob Key :
I agree. wasnt expecting a 4 for that dance but I do love and respect it.
2026-10-28 01:56:08
61
Lulu :
This only works if all contestants have similar style (all contemporary, all Latinn all ballroom) imo. Because the contemporary ones got scored SO much higher because they're more free while the stricter dances got crushed and it makes it so unfair
2026-10-28 04:52:55
1
Hailey :
Need more of Shirley
2026-10-28 02:43:11
1
Aubrey.xoxo :
everyone's faces when that 4 came out was hilarious. I felt bad cause I love the dance but I do like the strong critiques
2026-10-28 00:46:28
529
Wildlife Wifey :
It wasn't her best dance, but it didn't deserve a 4. A 6, yes. A 4 is as if she danced like Guillermo. Ridiculous.
2026-10-28 02:35:39
22
Brittney | Pages & Planning :
I would love Shirley Kym and Derek as the judge panel
2026-10-28 01:53:36
80
alaina :
I like when they get feedback but the core three judges have established a 6/7 as the kinda baseline score for dances that were okay, so having a judge come in and give a 4 to someone on week 7 who hasn’t gotten something that low since week 1 feels off.
2026-10-28 02:23:27
8
Amanda :
I really wanted them to go home tonight 😭
2026-10-28 02:08:51
7
Catalina :
As long as its consistent between everyone I’m fine with it
2026-10-28 02:20:53
7
delilah🥂 :
i just love how shirley doesn’t give a shit and gives her honest opinion. i loved tonight
2026-10-28 02:09:30
18
To see more videos from user @lindspaigeeee, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.