I'd argue that comments or kudos are more akin to a "thank you" for receiving a gift than an act of reciprocity, which would be giving a gift of comparative value in return. It would be wild to expect even one person who reads to fic to write one back, or something equivalent. It's not that wild for writers to expect a percentage of readers would leave a thank you.
2026-11-03 20:34:14
25
Misty Roxy :
I've seen an argument being made that people would never do it to a fan artist so why are they doing it to fan authors (made by authors who are upset by the drives) but for me it misses what you just touch upon. fan artists exist in a slightly different area of fandom, they post their art and a lot of them relay on people following THEIR accounts and giving likes and shares from THEIR accounts so the algorithm works to make THEIR page more visible since for a lot of them it's a source of income, they operate in a more gray area when it comes to monetary gains from their fandom works, they often sell their art at cons or online, they take commissions, they much more often than fan writers have patreon, they make comics on webtoon they monetize etc. etc. so the etiquette of sharing and interacting with art is different with them (they often use fandom platforms to secure art jobs outside from fandom too) whereas fic writers are doing all of this veryyyyyyyy seldom. like I know there are some people who take fic commissions or who hope they will get discovered and traditionally published or who have patreon where they f.ex. post smut scenes from their fics or other works etc. BUT it's not the norm, it's very unusual I would even say since fics operate mostly in this gift economy you've mentioned
2026-11-03 21:03:04
7
whomst :
I was mostly afraid of the way I foresaw this fandom spinning out while ao3 was down rather than being without the site for a few weeks. I’ve seen increasing numbers of authors say they’re going to take down their fics when it’s back up or quit writing all together and it’s just such a bummer.
2026-11-03 20:51:32
5
Jenny :
Redistribution (on the scale of massive Google drives or other websites) is legitimately against ao3’s terms of service though. And most authors that I’ve seen upset about it (other than the fear of ai scraping) just feel like they’ve been essentially cut out of the community. They are totally fine with ppl downloading the fics to read offline or share with their group of friends. What they don’t like is this mass-scale redistribution that cuts them out of the picture
2026-11-06 17:06:04
2
NightOfStarFall🚦🇨🇦 :
people are threatening to leave and you know what? I am fine with that. I don't want to read stories from people who think that someone having downloaded their work (and now sharing it so other can enjoy it) is the worst thing you can do to an author. Fanfic is supposed to be about a love for a stories or characters so deep you have to create more for them, about sharing that with others because you know they love those characters/stories just as much as you. and while yes, I don't think its crazy thatan author wants hits or kudos, god knows I want those thing too, I do thing it is a problem when the desire for hits/kudos eclipses the love for creating. I think this will give a fantastic "back to basics" hit if those authors leave and I think its going to be a lot less than people assume bc while they are loud, they will be a minority of people.
2026-11-08 14:22:41
3
Izzy :
While I understand why people would want to be rewarded by their hard work. I don’t think anyone who wants that should publish works on a free to read site.
2026-11-03 21:09:01
17
Caz :
I find the whole uploading so sad as it will result in less stories as some authors are upset and they have spent many hours writing these wonderful stories. Also fandoms has a culture which I agree but cultures change and grow and the fans need to do that as well as you say where drives came from. It has changed.
2026-11-04 21:28:51
3
To see more videos from user @t3mp3s77, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.