@madmuna_: x2 it if needed, but pls don't respond if you have not watched it to the end 😭 💕#fyp #anthropology #blackfeminism #blackbritish

madmuna
madmuna
Open In TikTok:
Region: GB
Saturday 07 November 2026 02:25:02 GMT
15366
1450
142
140

Music

Download

Comments

rt48167
RT :
Who is “she”what are talking about???
2026-11-07 14:03:04
8
wimaniajosephs
Worokom :
Someone in the comment said I hope you’re not defending her just because East African aswell she’s 🇪🇹 like???
2026-11-07 17:33:52
52
bigoleanimetits
QUARANTINO SUPERSTAR :
*identity reductionism
2026-11-07 03:07:42
84
laurathesoloexplorer
laurathesoloexplorer :
I will say your video is articulated MUCH better than the original creator of this discussion. However, I still think you’re perhaps missing *why* black representation can sometimes be quite shallow or lack breadth of the black lived experience. I think it places such onus on the oppressed group (black women), instead of critiquing the systems in place which intentionally reduce the black experience to be portrayed into such a limited thing. Also, you both neglect the fact that time is a key factor here, just a few decades ago in the U.K. there were signs all around saying “no Blacks, no Irish, no dogs” and so to progress from times like that to now where black women are given a crumb of opportunity, platform and space to voice their experiences it will most definitely be led by their black identity and understandably so, living in a time where we’re still having to fight for a seat at the table- still fighting to be seen or heard. It’s not lost on me that especially in media/art, the black identity is often portrayed as one thing- very limited. That’s intentional. It’s why we can’t exactly detach from that black identity because it’s so deeply embedded into society’s perception of us, and until those racist systems are truly dismantled, I urge my black sisters to be very vocal about their blackness- especially monoracial black women whose representation is literally being erased and often replaced with biracial women. To detach from that identity is to silence BW and to appease the oppressor IMO. I think this conversation can circle back when black people aren’t still fighting to exist, to be seen, to be heard- to be given a seat. We’re still hearing “firsts” in relation to black people entering high spaces in 2026 and you’re expecting them to not be very loud about their blackness identity?? That’s unfair and quite frankly lacking in empathy IMO. Be careful, sometimes intellectualising absolutely everything can result in compassionless takes, which dismiss real lived experiences.
2026-11-07 10:52:21
61
ayoilesanmii
Plantainpapi :
The example of Palantir in BlackinTech made this make even more sense. Thx
2026-11-07 08:35:13
121
loanemwiza
Loane :
I think for me the problem with both what you and her are saying is that, this in turns but the blame on the black woman - before those that have put them in spaces where they think that the only way to survive is to be individualistic rather than rise as a community. The Palantir example for instance, why do we have three videos right now talking about the work that black women need to do instead of the harms that palantir is causing which is predominantly non-black. Secondly, black women are not the only ones that use “identity politics”, we see arabic women using said wording, hispanic women. I don’t know if it is as prevalent in the UK, but it is in the US and so the whole video being about black women - and the examples being about specifically black american women - then this video is seen as nothing more than an extra burden that yet again black women have to carry. Black men do the same too, but both of these videos did not mention any of that. Lastly, black women - black american women especially - who mention their identity before whatever other qualifications they have, is to acknowledge that they are their despite all the roadblocks that they have had to maneuver to be in the same space. Something other groups of people - whether minority or not - have not have to go through. BECAUSE BLACK WOMEN ARE AT THE BOTTOM OF THE FOOD CHAIN. And I think the point you make is a good point, that some people of color continue to benefit in spaces that other same people of color are struggling from. But let me ask you a question, name one black woman in the west that is not benefiting from the struggle and blood of other marginalized groups in other underdeveloped countries. We are all writing and making these videos on iPhones and Samsungs, etc… for christ sakes, when we know exactly what Sudanese and Congolese people are going through. The idea that then a video should be made to criticize a black woman for taking advantage of said space - this is not defend the palantir example but to kind of show the hypocrisy in the statement itself - instead of actually calling these white folks that have built systems that even when you win, you have to work against
2026-11-11 08:06:39
9
deetweets
Deetoks :
This is why I saw foolish people hyping up Kemi Badenoch on here this week
2026-11-07 11:12:11
19
hayaat_nk
Hayaat❤️‍🔥 :
A difference can’t be made *within* the system but I don’t see people walking away from the system/sacrificing a bag to make any useful change too. Individualism is upheld this way!
2026-11-09 02:58:17
24
gulbil.34
Awo :
I honestly understood it as “black women in…” is becoming “the girl boss” trope that diluted centuries of feminist work into capitalist garbage but then everyone got mad and I got insecure and thought maybe I didn’t get it
2026-11-09 17:20:54
24
moneylovepower
moneylovepower :
The video has attracted the "stop making it about race" dogwhistle people so what was the purpose of the video?
2026-11-09 09:26:06
12
yuukopt
yuukopt :
What tell are you talking about ?
2026-11-07 22:32:21
14
shombi111
shubztheecreator :
I think her video just wasn’t worded the best - I get what she was saying but I think this video (esp linking to spaces like tech) articulates the point much more solidly
2026-11-07 14:30:48
22
limpwristhardfist
Ethan :
Speaking specifically about the UK, what do you think is the effect of the population being so small? Especially the population of Black Brits who participate in these fields where identity labelling is so common (arts/creative, tech, business etc). I always wonder if the unwillingness to critique shallow politics of representation is partially due to genuine proximity to [e.g.] BWatPalantir types and the allure of potential inclusion in that group. I can only really speak for creatives as that’s the field I work in, but I often feel that people are unwilling to critique those with relatively small degrees of social removal from themselves, and who they see as proximate and/or potential collaborators/fellow in-group members. Perhaps in the UK identity politics and demographics have conspired to created a warping effect whereby the few black people permitted to ‘represent’ the group as a whole can appear closer to oneself that one’s actual class peers?
2026-11-07 15:26:42
19
christina.adane
CONSUMING :
Thank you for articulating this so well !!!!!
2026-11-07 09:43:27
37
theglobalmajorityreader
Ann-Marie 🇿🇲 :
Can’t find that book anywhere ! Thank you for reading from it
2026-11-09 22:53:39
2
sophsw0rld.04
S :
I think you’ve done a great job at explaining the part that creates a lot of cognitive dissonance in those watching the video. It’s resisting our notions of representation by taking us further. However, it is hard to see and implement in a lot of people’s realties and that’s what makes it controversial.
2026-11-07 15:09:37
47
lslsksksksskslsldlkskdkd
Moomeh :
I think the point that she thought that she was articulating stands (the commodification of blackness in art and consumer culture) but this isn’t really her point is it? Considering the amount of tangential arguments and contradictions espoused in that video. I think for someone who is obviously trying to be as informed or enlightened about the things that she observes in society, there are a lot of basic misunderstandings of the phenomena that she critiques
2026-11-08 02:22:40
7
n.8799
n :
Sigh
2026-11-07 10:03:22
21
_mxrysm
Maryam :
Well said 👏
2026-11-07 12:38:57
6
maamiwata
maamiwata :
We should be building reading lists in comment sections not doing up identity take downs. Radical literature for the masses is so so urgent!
2026-11-11 23:44:44
2
princesss.nx
themissingteletubby :
I think what you’re saying and what she’s saying are quite different tbh. I completely agree that we can take representation further and we should push for more always.
2026-11-12 12:56:32
0
funnycoolgirl67
funnycoolgirl67 :
so eloquently put lovely x
2026-11-11 13:29:53
1
koehunaziz
Koehun :
nailed it
2026-11-09 20:25:12
2
prophet.asantia
Prophet Asantia :
Well said !!!!!
2026-11-08 01:07:06
3
To see more videos from user @madmuna_, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About