@realfarmerjeff: As you might know, planting larger garlic cloves will generally produce larger bulbs. But here's the craziest part: I actually separated all of my biggest cloves from the seed garlic and planted them in the first bed. That means the bulbs that ended up being three times smaller should have actually had the potential to grow even bigger than the giant bulbs in the other bed. This experience has really changed how I'm approaching next year's garden. It's a good reminder that while starting with quality seeds and plants matters, your soil can make an enormous difference in the results you get.