@gonghonglei: 作为曾经成吉思汗创建的大蒙古国一部分，喀尔喀部始终只是帝国的边缘地带和边缘群体。今天以喀尔喀为中心的历史叙事，天然与大蒙古国的历史有继承性冲突，今天的蒙古国既放不下喀尔喀中心主义，又想要继承泛蒙古主义思潮，而这对矛盾似乎难以调和#搬運 #蒙古 #喀爾喀中心主義 #mongolia #Mongolian

REstet :

这些部落都在我们哈萨克族里面的部落到今天还在 、所以成吉思汗是 哈萨克族

远方 :

蒙古人不是拍了个电影嘛，明朝时期的，有个满都海皇后的，那里面有个太师为首的势力专门暗杀黄金家族后裔，几乎被杀完了都

arma-tdk :

我是克列部落，妈妈是乃曼，妻子是蔑尔齐特部落。是哈萨克族。

Baketbek Nasiphan :

他说的是100%✅，蒙古国是这不过是斯大林的战略目标而已，成吉思汗不是蒙古是哈萨克族。

Шыңғысхан :

宝鹰 :

说的很对

Roster :

Perhaps Genghis Khan never existed at all—there was only the DaiMeng Dynasty.

Bolat Sharipkhan :

说的很好👍👍👍

Sskguo :

Yuan was an imperial Chinese dynasty, Outer Mongolia was part of China. Mongol armies were not even solely ethnic Mongols to begin with, who were just a small minority. During the 13th century, when Mongol political power emerged, it served more as a political and military alliance identity. The overwhelming majority that made up the Mongol armies were different peoples and tribes, including the vast majority from various steppe Turkic tribes, Northern Han Chinese warlord armies with siege warfare engineer forces, Persian and Central Asian soldiers, Eastern European conscripts, Muslim engineers, and others. It was a massive, heavily multi-ethnic military force. Many ethnic Mongols remained under Ming dynasty as subjects after Yuan dynasty collapsed and served under the Han Chinese imperial imperial military of Ming. Mongol identity only emerged in the 13th century, and during that time, it was also a political identity and military alliance. Its armies were overwhelmingly multi-ethnic, not solely ethnic Mongols, and included huge numbers of northern Han Chinese warlords and siege warfare engineers. When battling with Chinese dynasties, it was the vast majority Han Chinese forces that did the fighting. The Southern Song eventually fell when large numbers of its imperial Han Chinese army and navy defected, and it was eventually conquered by Han Chinese forces themselves. Yuan dynasty was established with massive Han Chinese military support and participation. Although the royal family was ethnic Mongol, Yuan was ruled under the Han Chinese imperial political system and institutions. The government and military were overwhelming majority Han Chinese officials, generals, and soldiers throughout its reign. Yuan succeeded the Song as the next ruling Chinese dynasty.

Sskguo :

Mongol empire and armies are often overstated and overexaggerated. Mongol armies were not even solely ethnic Mongols to begin with, who were just a small minority. During the 13th century, when Mongol political power emerged, the name Mongol served more as a political and military alliance identity not solely ethnic Mongols. The overwhelming majority that made up the Mongol armies were different peoples and tribes, including from various steppe Turkic tribes, Northern Han Chinese warlords armies with siege warfare and firearms expertise, Persian and Central Asian soldiers, Eastern European conscripts, Muslim engineers, and others. It was a massive, heavily multi-ethnic military war machine. Mongols armies campaign against Chinese dynasties were vast majority, at least 90 percent were Han Chinese warriors and military forces and Southern Song dynasty was conquered by Han Chinese generals and soldiers when massive numbers of Southern Song Han Chinese imperial army and navy defected. It took total 77 years for China campaigns and Southern Song dynasty alone tool 44 years to fell. Where other countries just fell within weeks, months and few years.

James Tang :

博主的有关游牧民族的历史知识很丰富 👍

sawkuanlam6 :

蒙古被老毛愚弄了百年！仇中教育搞窮了自己？

running bing :

内蒙的察哈尔部和鄂尔多斯部应该正统性多，外蒙喀尔喀部祖上是成吉思汗掳掠的奴隶？

安安 :

说的对，没有苏联的干预，蒙古还真的独立不了。

QJ :

是生不逢时，还是烂泥扶不上墙

ben :

Manchur Khalkha came from china

凤山居士 :

追木求源是对的

Serik Aytnbek :

成吉思汗本来就是哈萨克

明明天 :

其实跟满洲人是一样的，以反中来建立自己的民族，因反中仇华而存在

Nurmuhamet :

今天的哈萨克斯坦 是真正的黄金家族 成吉思汗帝国的后代

Zaza777 :

他说的对

user4612518335586 :

🥰🥰🥰

Nonickname :

👏👏👏

Landmark Insights 届标 :

😁😁😁