@truewilayahofficial: Omar and Fatima’s House….. A sahih hadith from Ibn Saad’s Tabaqat that challenges the notion that Omar ibn al-Khattab would never attack the house of Fatima. The incident where Omar beat Umm Farwa, the sister of Abu Bakr, for mourning her brother, demonstrating his willingness to use force against women who opposed him. We argue this shows his personality could lead to such actions. #shia #muslim #sunni #viralvideo #reminder

Shahzad Nasir :

you are right I agree now tell me what was reaction of imam Ali A.S on this incident

Meher Zain Ul Abidin :

So you are trying to say Imam Ali was afraid of Umar bin Khattab that is why he didn’t avenge?

A.A. :

these fitnahs started long ago by people to devide the ummah. even if it was true Allah will deal with person even if he was Khalifa..lets unit and not devide

أويس حسين المجيد 🇮🇶 :

Brother Allah bless you why you spreading a false information For a second. If Umar ibni AL khitab RA attack on Imam Ali house So you wanna saying that (imam Ali AS) lion of GOD was silent on this issue

Kief Mary Jane :

the narration is mursal , not sahih

No one :

he is completely lying

Adnan Paracha :

and when U quote a sahih hadith where is the sahih hadith about the incident why there is the need to interprate.

Waheed Speeder :

reference??,??😒😒

صيام ظفر :

The primary chain for this report goes through al-Zuhri from Sa'id ibn al-Musayyib. While classical scholars like Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani noted that the chain up to Sa'id ibn al-Musayyib is sound, Sa'id was born two to four years after the death of Abu Bakr (during Umar's caliphate). Because Sa'id did not witness the event and did not name the companion he heard it from, the report is classified in hadith sciences including under al-Albani's strict criteria as disconnected (mursal or munqati'), which renders it weak (da'if) unless supported by independent, continuous chains.

Monkey32 :

it happened 1400 years ago , how about leave it till day of judgement . none of us will be able to find those Shaba , so I don't know what these Sheikh getting out of swearing at then

Mj :

If Umar had surely attacked and hurt and killed Fatima as you say,then surely not only Ali ra but also other companions would kill Umar for this murder but Ali took no action neither did any other companions which means your story is wrong.Ali was the best fighter of all the companions and he could take revenge but he didn’t which clearly shows that no matter the disagreement,Umar never reached the level of hurting Fatima ra

Aisha Uzma :

This is definitely true

Hassy :

Allah knows the truth brother don't use imaginations on your own.

naomi2005678 :

I cannot deny the truth and what they did to Sayyida Fatima

heer🌷 :

Shadow ♠ :

The amount of hate I've seen on the comments from so called shia

Ahmed S.a. :

insensible explanation..

❤️Lion Of Allah ALI❤️ :

♥️♥️♥️

ilovenq2000 :

Zero48 🇲🇦 :

Omar was a badass 😂

Buzz :

in Islam crying loud or too much on deaths is not good

SHAMIR :

it's not like this and Umar didn't had problem but prophet Muhammad s.a.w so prophet Muhammad s.a.w banned crying loudly it was not done by Umar it was done by prophet and Umar just enforced it because Umar was very strict and since it was an law made by prophet Muhammad s.a.w so hazrat Umar just enforced the law because in his time he would do justice equally with everyone no matter who is he so Umar just enforced something which was done by prophet Muhammad s.a.w so don't fabricate it please

omar yaqoob :

you don't get this and I don't get as to why and how; Asad Allah Al Ghaalib Ali Ibn ABI Talib A.S would let this attack be conducted whilst he is present inside the house and let the attackers just simply attack and go by instead of toppling his khilafa in the honour and defence of The women of Jannah and the Deen of Her father SAW. no hate here, just a thought of the naivety and impossibility of such an event to take place in the presence of the courageous of all Imam Ali A.S and not only that but later on during the khilafa of Sayyudna Umar R.A he, imam Ali A.S, carried on with advicing Umar R.A in political matters and also fetching Malik Al Ashtar to join the army during the conquests.

wajiii :

refernce?