Emotions are rational 😁 they are messengers about needs 💚
2026-11-18 20:49:49
0
Fizz :
I hate when anyone argues that emotion isnt valid like its not a core part of the human experience
2026-11-15 22:31:24
323
Amina :
Emotivism
2026-11-15 20:45:19
31
I'm Master Baiter :
This is why I love science is because it searches for the ultimate truth not meaning
2026-11-15 23:36:29
60
angelxgalore :
I love this thought and think there is a lot of truth to it but I still disagree because I have been an atheist all my life and it does not bring me comfort at all. But comfort seeking is not my basis for understanding truth. I wish it were true that death is not simply nothingness after I die like the nothingness before I was born. I don’t want to go back to not existing. Life is inherently full of grief because of the inevitability of the deaths of others and the death of self. I am constantly grieving. I would rather only smile, laugh, sing, dance and eat. I don’t want death to be nothingness. That brings me zero comfort. And yet it is true. I hate it.
2026-11-15 22:01:30
31
BoyEmily :
ok, I'll bite. my adhd nervous system needs whimsy to function and maintain routine and I like pretty rocks. so much of tarot and zodiac analysis is community connection with other women, and it's a fun way to use language/story telling to be introspective. do i literally believe in reincarnation... maybe? I don't know for sure, and neither do you, but in the meantime I like my routines, my community, and my pretty rocks. ultimately people who are spiritual aren't always (some of us are traumatized) trying to get you to believe when we talk to you about our pretty rocks, it's just an open bid for connection.
2026-11-15 22:01:30
61
joshyeary0 :
This would be amazing, not just for the debate itself but for the purpose of getting them all to confront the deeper foundations they have built their beliefs on.
2026-11-19 13:45:28
1
10_something_interesting :
I feel emotionally I wanted to stay believer about my logic just couldn't not see how religions were developed by people so I'm not sure losing faith benefited me emotionally i just can't unsee that humans created God and not the opposite...
2026-11-19 15:59:07
0
skepticalcats :
The truth is that no one can have this kind of metacognition as it conflicts with the need to hold true the beliefs they are meta-analyzing... If religious people just recognize their truth is so fragile as to be based on a need, not on objective reality, religion will cease to exist as an ideology.
2026-11-18 22:52:34
2
George_Lincoln_Rockwell :
If our cognitive faculties are a product of unguided evolution aimed solely for survival rather than truth, then it raises a serious question about whether we as a species have sufficient grounds to trust those faculties to deliver reliable knowledge?
2026-11-15 22:40:38
7
firstbest7777 :
The requirements would be honesty or transparency with oneself AND the ability to verbalize it, let alone the willingness to do so in front of other people in [!real-time!]. I’m just thinking about all the cuts that have to be made recording such a debate bc of the real-time emotional reactions with the real-time emotional processes within each person during the debate….
2026-11-19 20:51:14
0
Trumpers are Neo-Nzs :
how can people act like facts dont exist? believing that emotions are the "source" of all ideas falls directly under the "ok and" category. lets says it's true, then all those groups have it so it changes nothing. the layers of fact and data on top of those emotions (allegedly) is what makes those groups different and where the debate would be (if there was one).
2026-11-15 20:28:11
16
JessBuKrahnan :
This would be amazing, although I fear far too few people are self aware enough to name the emotional aspects of why their preferred worldview is what they prefer
2026-11-15 20:25:01
60
Summer 🌞 :
I think if they had this self awareness they wouldn’t be debating
2026-11-15 21:37:47
27
choose.a_day :
Ughhh it works in theory but it would be hard to navigate in practice. Rationality goes beyond just being safer or tolerable. If all arguments were individualistic than every debate wouldn't be two defending their religion or collective worldview at each other. They'd be defending their feelings, it would be fun to see but like you suggested its counter intuitive and not productive in the grand scheme of things.
2026-11-15 20:30:19
11
sinking lessons :
even though I'm emotionally drawn towards absurdism and am incredibly allergic to religion from trauma, the statistics you've offered on spiritual practice offering more well being gave me a window to dabble in a detached faith and yknow what it's going pretty great. you're a wonderful human
2026-11-15 21:59:34
4
Hannah 🩷 :
you're so right. please do it. organize this
2026-11-15 20:42:43
9
mossynook_ :
That would be so interesting to see. And no one wins a debate like that. It just makes people understand each other better
2026-11-15 22:27:00
6
Jeff4Truth :
I am not motivated by emotional needs. I am motivated by truth and the universe most DEFINATELY supports truth. We do not live in a subjective, unreliable reality. There is objective truth but people are motivated by emotion rather than truth.
2026-11-17 15:57:06
0
NoliCedere :
Except I believe because it's rational, not because of emotion. I mostly observe the world through logic rather than emotions, and I even subject my emotions to logic. Although, this isn't a perfect system and it's very complex. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding you.
2026-11-16 16:28:07
0
john.is.normal :
Emotion weighs too much. It’s possible to have emotions, and to not be of them. In fact, emotions are like bloood pressure and has no say in the relationship between force and mass. Isness doesn’t care about emotions.
2026-11-15 23:05:36
2
tobi :
There's no proof that any religion is true. That's my argument. It's pretty simple. No emotions required
2026-11-16 20:59:08
0
Creatieve Revolte :
Belief Is not only based on feelings, also personal symbols and pattern recognition
2026-11-15 22:23:10
2
Ethan Ross :
honestly, I agree. I would love to see a debate like this. I would even love to discuss and debate topics like this in such manner. this is such a great idea that I might start using more.
2026-11-17 20:34:13
1
mikexbhere :
why don't you host that panel at the Deconstructicon!! I would definitely pay to watch that
2026-11-15 21:59:17
4
To see more videos from user @nononsensespirituality, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.