The parts have their own relatives. ATP synthase's catalytic head is related to hexameric ATPases and helicases (the RecA-like fold). Its membrane rotor resembles ion channels and protein-translocation machinery. Mulkidjanian and colleagues (2007, Nature Reviews Microbiology) proposed it arose by combining a helicase-like RNA translocase with a membrane protein translocase.
• There's a family tree. The F-, V- and A-type rotary ATPases are recognisable variants of one design spread across the domains of life. The rotor's c-ring varies between roughly 8 and 17 subunits depending on the organism. That pattern of variation is what descent with modification predicts. A design built once to a fixed spec wouldn't need it.
Why Haldane was half right. Large animals with wheels really don't exist, and the reason is mundane. A part that spins freely can't be supplied with blood vessels or nerves. At the molecular scale that problem disappears, because a protein ring doesn't need plumbing. So "no wheels" was a fact about anatomy at large scales. It wasn't a limit on what evolution can build.
In short, the creationist case quotes a failed prediction as if it were an agreed falsification test. It then ignores the homology evidence, which shows how the "useless until complete" premise breaks down.
2026-11-20 22:04:04
1
dsmith :
religions make no predictions about reality
2026-11-20 22:49:27
0
l5ndonorris :
“One person in 1949, there for god” 😂😂😂😂😂
2026-11-21 08:40:08
0
r8mysteez :
Proton gradients this n that
2026-11-21 03:04:36
0
CreationMinistriesInt. :
For more info, see the full interview with Mark James (link in profile):
→ ‘Machines in your Cells That Defy Evolution’ – youtu.be/50rpNEq6-k
2026-11-20 21:32:11
0
l5ndonorris :
Desperation
2026-11-21 06:13:46
0
creep1ngtheycast :
One guy all the way back in 1949 said evolution can’t make a wheel and all of a sudden evolution cant make a wheel? What about all the modern scientists who disagree?
2026-11-20 23:49:45
0
G :
why does that matter. where is it written large that we should have all the answers by now or that we have any relationship with 'the truth' we're learning more about our reality every day. it's not either evolution or God. like it's up to us, like it's up to human believe. reality is what it is, obviously there is some form of evolution involved and we'll keep getting closer to the thruth.
2026-11-20 21:45:27
0
LungColin :
By your logic, the fact that Christ has never returned on any of the many dates predicted over the centuries disproved Christianity...😂
2026-11-21 04:27:14
0
To see more videos from user @creationministries, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.