Lisa Martinez :
I find it deeply troubling that we have reached a point where speaking out against the mass killing, displacement, and suffering of innocent Palestinians is somehow being equated with antisemitism.
First, let’s establish something that seems to be getting lost in these conversations.
Palestinians are a Semitic people, too. Arabic and Hebrew are both Semitic languages. However, the term antisemitism has a specific historical meaning: hatred, prejudice, or discrimination against Jewish people.
Now, here’s where critical thinking becomes essential.
Condemning the actions of a government is NOT the same as condemning an entire religious or ethnic population.
Opposing the devastation in Gaza does not mean you hate Jewish people. Demanding accountability for the Israeli government’s actions does not mean you oppose Judaism. And advocating for Palestinian lives does not mean you believe Israeli lives are worth any less.
You can condemn Hamas’s attacks against civilians AND condemn the killing of Palestinian civilians. These positions are not mutually exclusive.
Human rights are not conditional upon nationality, ethnicity, religion, or political affiliation.
And perhaps most importantly, no government should be immune from criticism simply because of the religious or ethnic identity of the people it claims to represent.
Real antisemitism exists, and it deserves to be confronted unequivocally. But labeling every criticism of Israel as antisemitic risks undermining the seriousness of actual antisemitism while silencing legitimate concerns about human rights.
I do not stand against Jewish people. I do not stand against Palestinians. I stand against the dehumanization, persecution, and killing of innocent human beings. PERIOD.
If your compassion only extends to people who share your religion, nationality, or political beliefs, then perhaps it’s time to examine whether you’re defending human rights or simply defending a side.
Humanity should never have to choose whose children deserve to live.
2026-11-21 07:27:21