@jamaalburkmar: Is this better in the books?? Because this whole thing feels incredibly manufactured in a terribly hacky and cash grabby way. #whattowatch

Jamaal Burkmar
Jamaal Burkmar
Open In TikTok:
Region: US
Saturday 21 November 2026 11:23:42 GMT
191802
14911
495
342

Music

Download

Comments

smoozeydos
Snowlite02 :
Haymitch in the original Hunger Games movies is also tamed down. He is much worse in the books. He is so drunk at the reaping he falls off the stage and causes a huge scene.
2026-11-21 12:18:50
4518
laylah.rigney
Laylah Rigney Psychologist :
I don’t really agree with “no one comes out of this” there are very real people going through things worse than Haymich and are in fact coming out of it. Not everyone lives in our privileged reality.
2026-11-21 14:52:13
756
a0oqa
🪡 :
how can you say it’s bad writing if you haven’t read the book..?
2026-11-21 12:46:02
1050
fadeupyoursmile
fadeupyoursmile🍉 :
In the book he almost becomes catatonic... and claws his way out when he realises that he is going to have two kids to mentor for the next horror show. In the first set of books I assumed he lost everything over time, like after time he became more settled after the trauma of the games- house fire. I assumed he was punished for YEARS... Not "boy has the worst month ever". The films have an awful habit of ignoring the mental breakdowns of its main characters - Katniss has multiple attempts in between killing coin and heading back to 12. At the beginning of Mockingjay she wears a bracelet saying she is "mentally unstable".
2026-11-21 12:43:32
1709
hannah.grace_c
hannah :
he vowed to live to see a sunrise without a reaping. he’s surviving through alcoholism
2026-11-21 13:14:41
748
loonietooney
loonie 🪆 :
I think yall don't understand how bad alcoholism is, as someone with multiple alcoholics in my family
2026-11-21 13:39:59
758
emmahalvorsen1
Emma Halvorsen :
The book was incredible I’m not even engaging
2026-11-21 11:59:28
735
dessi_tonch
dessi_tonch :
Thank you! Also, as a psychologist, nowhere in the book is it shown how he develops this “intelligent sarcastic personality”. Like it’s assumed that trauma=intelligence, but no. It’s not shown how he learns these lessons. And he is a a completely different person as a youth, VERY naive. I was so interested in this development, but the book is just suffering porn
2026-11-21 11:35:25
505
sgonzalesauthor
Sophie Gonzales :
Respectfully disagree, also as a psychologist! It’s completely true that many people could not cope with that level of trauma, but it’s also true that other people dissociate or have other coping mechanisms. The only reason I’m bothering to argue the point is that it’s a known issue within trauma counselling that a lot of people will diminish their own trauma because “if it was really that bad, I wouldn’t have achieved xyz with my life”.
2026-11-21 12:54:49
185
tmacca
TMACCA :
tbh I was more than ok thinking he was an alcoholic as a result of the trauma from experiencing a “normal” games in addition to having to mentor kids to their deaths year after year
2026-11-21 12:31:19
315
agoatsprivatelife
goat :
Well tbh in the movies they really toned down how drunk he was. In the books he is constantly blacking out and falling. He doesn’t even look that bad in the movies in my opinion.
2026-11-21 19:27:05
122
pnwsiren13
Nova🍁🐋 :
In the books he is in no way ok, they definitely down play it in the movies
2026-11-21 12:19:35
196
daisythomas03
🦦🪸 :
his promise to lenore dove, his love for his family, his anger and his HOPE for a better future kept him alive. It was the inly thing he was thinking about, he drank to stay alive so that he could one day make all of the deaths he witnessed and experienced mean something
2026-11-22 03:12:01
0
alex_.._09
alex_.._09 :
Haymitch sleeps with a knife every night which was mentioned in catching he does have obvious signs of ptsd/trauma
2026-11-21 14:13:59
46
parkerslittlepeople
Parker :
Yeah so you not having read the book is why you think this way. He is on drugs, drinking and wandering around half asleep because he can't get any rest with his PTSD dreams, for like a year until they show up and make him mentor the next year's kids. And when they do show up, he nearly kills his prep team. He nearly ends his life but because he can never stop dreaming about Lenore Dove, he ends up taking up her fight of never letting another sun rise on the reaping as his reason for living, but doesn't actually do much to make that happen for the first 25 years because he cannot get himself out of his stuppor. And he is more bitter and more violent in the OG trilogy of books than the movies. They tone him down a lot in the movies
2026-11-22 00:57:34
0
juxtaposie
JoFeMaMoP :
The book was so awful. I felt like it really underplayed his intelligence and stripped him of all agency. We get very little from the original trilogy about him, except for two things - he’s smart and he’s dangerous. The book was just things happening to him and there were indeed moments in the book when I literally laughed out loud for how ridiculous it was. He was my favorite supporting character in the trilogy, and I was just so disappointed in SotR.
2026-11-21 19:37:08
1
dared8vil
dared8vil :
u should read the book
2026-11-22 01:43:11
0
reginaaaa_george
regina :
i think most of y’all are overlooking how powerful the message of this whole book was , sm interesting topics about how they manipulated the media so much they believed he betrayed everyone to win just so snow could still be in power it’s kinda what we’re going through irl , the fact he still held on even though he lived the worst and was punished for it … ofc the book has flaws yet I think it was a very good addition to the og trilogy story and the other prequel
2026-11-21 19:50:42
1
atomicbomb_shell
KATIE :
Have you read The Happiest Man on Earth? Jaku survived TWO concentration camps and went on to live a life he adored. Everyone responds differently to trauma.
2026-11-21 14:09:17
58
thatgingerannoyance
ThatGingerAnnoyance :
I see your point but what I think the film missed that the book did, that to me kind of explained how he survived it for me, is that he did have Burdock and Astrid for a while after he came back whereas in the film he chased them off really fast. And the fact that there are so many years between his games and Katniss let him have his worst, arguably probably suicidal years, before she gets to him. Haymitch is a profoundly traumatized man trying to keep his promise to Maysilee and be the worst victor in history, that’s practically all he’s living for.
2026-11-21 11:31:56
197
justhippocampus
Justhippocampus :
The whole point is he was holding on to fulfill his promise to his girl. All of these tributes survived stories this bad his is only one they survived because they are survivors but it breaks them in other ways.
2026-11-21 21:04:25
11
ajl6417
Andrew :
The only reason he was alive was because of the promise to his girlfriend easily understood if you read the books
2026-11-21 13:21:16
27
forestfirefox2
Foxy :
In the books he drinks far more. Katniss has to physically stop him more than once to get him to help them and he's very much not interested in being alive. And that's like 10-20 years later
2026-11-21 19:37:07
33
charlieslibrary
Charlie 🪿 | BookTok :
The thing is we already knew the hardships of Haymitch’s games because we “see” them in Catching Fire. We know how Maysilee dies. We know how Haymitch wins. We know what happens after. This wasn’t the book I wanted from Haymitch, I wanted actually how despite all of that, he still managed to join the rebellion and how he waited YEARS for it to take hold. Really, it should’ve been a novella. Not a whole book and certainly not a massive movie that took away small nuances that made scenes make sense
2026-11-21 11:52:47
64
yourgayclown
laura :
genuinely what are you even saying? what would you like haymitch to do? in the book it is stated that he sees lonore dove in his every dream, he sees her face like it’s haunting him every day of his life, so he drinks to not feel the pain and sleeps drunk without dreams. and he cannot unalive himself because he promised both lenore dove and maysilee that he won’t stop trying (while self-punishing himself year after year knowing the kids will not survive the arena) and someday he will stop the sunrise on the reaping day. his alcoholism is an escape mechanism, he’s basically been dissociating for 25 years
2026-11-21 12:16:51
131
To see more videos from user @jamaalburkmar, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About