@kaylatheshow: Is Miles Morales an expection to the rule? Does Severus Snape’s race actually matter to the plot of Harry Potter? Why does it feel like everyone is race swapped now? #tiktokworthtalkingaboutcontest

KaylaTheShow
KaylaTheShow
Open In TikTok:
Region: DE
Saturday 21 November 2026 12:10:13 GMT
177193
20174
1120
164

Music

Download

Comments

sunkissedstardust
ᴛᴇʟᴇᴀʜ ˎˊ˗ :
the only reason i believe snape should be white because him being black completely changes Harry’s judgement on his character and makes him seem like a racist
2026-11-21 13:55:07
5493
reiriku._313
rei_ :
James Potter hanged Snape from a tree upside down ...
2026-11-21 18:14:13
178
calebsmith664
Caleb Smith :
ok so heres the issue with making snape black. It makes Harry into a racist little shit, and makes James and serious into KKK members. James literally hangs snape upside down under a tree.
2026-11-21 17:18:14
281
alter.account.sec
alter acc :
the book constantly describing Snape with "greasy hair", "sallow skin/ pale face", "crooked nose", literally scary looking... and they give us... an attractive looking black man who had none of those?
2026-11-21 14:30:06
130
sewundenk
renzi🐝 :
i feel race swapping is a lazy forced representation. why would you swap a character's race from what it was originally interpreted, instead of making actual new characters on certain races that have been underrepresented.
2026-11-21 13:56:33
908
andydtiktok
Andy :
I completely agree. Snape is also hung up in the air by a bunch of white boys. Constantly told he looks untrustworthy because of how he looks. Surely that's more controversial. The other teachers it's not really an issue at all.
2026-11-21 13:06:11
972
sil.lykitty
ᜀᜎᜒᜌᜈ :
and im ngl race swapping Snape wouldve been more welcomed if they did it to other characters too but like, its just him?😭 they managed to do near identical castings for everyone else but him??? the one dude who gets bashed for his looks? 😭
2026-11-21 14:37:11
365
prongswastakenreee
ProngsWasTakenReee :
Race swapping Snape makes a lot of character irredeemable and change. Harry is suspicious of a black teacher, the marauders bully and hang in a tree a black kid, Snape gets saved by a white women. They will need to make a lot of changes for a lot of the character to not just seem racist.
2026-11-21 13:53:43
30
kroz.portal
Kroz Portal :
The issue with Snape being black is that he is a bully professor and a double agent on both sides pretty much and kinda the only major black character in the movie. Why mot have a black McGonagol?
2026-11-21 13:50:45
215
ryliesgame0
rylie/mushroom/bee :
so snapes race doesn't necessarily matter for his story, but he is described as a pale man. and his backstory is so much worse with him being black as he is treated horribly, and in the main story he is very much hated by the students. any other character would have been fine and I personally don't care all that much about race swapping. but for Snape it is such a bad choice.
2026-11-21 13:15:46
220
its_aj_yall
Aj :
also theres the fact that harry had a really bad feeling about Snape for what started as no tangible reason
2026-11-21 13:09:46
3545
bigboymikeh
Michael ✝️ :
The whole point of Spider-Man is that anybody can wear the mask. If miles only exists for black and Puerto rican kids he kind of goes against the whole point
2026-11-21 17:45:11
10
starfire.xcx
ᖭི༏ᖫྀ :
But you can’t make Snape black he’s literally describe as pale white in the books when Harry first meets him
2026-11-21 20:47:54
3
ilovespidergwen
《spider-gwen》 :
its so simple: if the race maters to the story or the caracter/place the caracter lives, it cant be swapped, if it does not matter it can be swapped
2026-11-21 12:33:51
746
returnofthesnorp
snorpreturns :
doesnt harry meet snape and for an unknown reason dislike him?
2026-11-21 19:11:04
2
mrbrittycat
Mr Britty Cat :
no Snape is different... it changes so much of the story...
2026-11-21 13:41:21
31
shannylou19
SLH19 :
There are so many characters in Harry Potter who could be race swapped without changing anything major about the character or story. But I think the people that need to be white are Snape, voldemort, the Weasleys, and the malfoys.
2026-11-21 17:07:45
2
floridianabbey3
Abbey :
Yes but in the books they describe him as greasy haired and sallow skinned with a large nose.. changing Snape black in the show is making everyone seem racist which makes it 10x worse as he was bullied horribly and kids will see this in theaters and haven’t read the books yet..
2026-11-21 19:27:40
1
vashthestampede6
VashTheStampede :
Snape is literally described in the books as having pale white skin….. so there’s that. Ariel’s father and mother are both white…. So there’s that.
2026-11-21 18:17:27
17
thejamieforever
The Jamie 🇬🇧 :
Or which shouldn't be a hot take: just leave the race as they original was cause there's no good reason to change it
2026-11-21 14:12:43
14
khloe.conklin
it's me :
or hot take we just leave all the characters how they are
2026-11-21 13:24:48
67
kenzie_elizabeth16
Kenzie :
Yeah, but for Harry Potter, it's different because when like James and all of them are bullying Snape, it's gonna come off racist now
2026-11-21 16:15:09
44
hunterxscarlet
Hunter Scarlet87 :
My problem with Snape being black is that Harry is inherently suspicious of Snape, and that there is something that makes Harry think he is secretly evil. This entire subplot feels very uncomfortable when the ONLY major black character is the one getting this treatment
2026-11-21 17:16:48
16
keiras04
Keira Stephens :
The books describe him as pale white with greasy hair not black with dreadlocks
2026-11-21 15:18:49
6
indigo5921
indi🤷‍♂️ :
Snape has to be white otherwise everyone gonna look racist as hell bc not alot if people like Snape at hogwarts
2026-11-21 15:09:37
33
To see more videos from user @kaylatheshow, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About