☆ banshee ☆ they/them
Region: CA
Saturday 04 July 2026 16:19:27 GMT
92327
10364
277
39
Music
Download
Comments
familiarcanids :
Criticising free fics is like telling ur mom that the cookies she baked for you are too chewy
2026-07-04 22:06:11
2761
dariamvs :
Theres also a difference between constructive criticism and bullying wrapped in bubblewrap
2026-07-04 16:33:17
1565
⧗paiton ⎊ :
this is the WORST thing that ever came my way as an author
2026-08-17 13:26:36
127
hanni .𖦹𓈒 ⊹ˑ ֗ ִ :
the only comment i’ve left :3
2026-08-12 12:23:48
78
sdold1 :
There’s literally an entire subReddit dedicated to calling out people who hate comment on fanfiction
2026-07-04 19:28:50
654
Juli Weizen :
I think the height of my fanfiction "critique" was something like "Hey! The first 2 paragraphs are repeated in this chapter, in case that was an accident and you wanna correct that😊" combined with a compliment about their work. I feel like that's the equivalent of telling someone their shoe laces are loose. Obviously by accident, fixable in 5 seconds.
2026-07-04 19:16:40
524
ne0fita_ :
What happened to “oh, i don’t like this fic, let’s close the tab and go find another” LIKE… ILL NEVER EVER SAY ANYTHING BAD TO ANY FANFIC AUTHOR
2026-07-04 20:49:51
2879
Ace And Fluid :
Literally the only time I give unasked for advice is to tell them that they got a tag wrong or a term mixed up that usually affects the audience intended to read the fic. And I can count the number of times I've even had to do that on one hand. Other than that, I stay in my lane and simply DNF if I don't like how it's being written
2026-07-04 17:35:23
390
Louis 🇦🇺 🏳️🌈 :
"if you don't have anything nice to say, say nothing at all" is the best rule when it comes to fan made things
2026-07-05 01:49:57
62
chronic_julia :
I still remember years ago when a dude pointed out a tiny mistake in my fic, but in the most arrogant way possible. I stopped writing on that fic that day (yes I was in a bad head space at that time, but still) now years later I started to think about writing fic again but I’m still scared
2026-08-17 20:41:28
9
Z :
As someone who writes fanfic it actually ruins my day getting comments that critique my writing, I know it’s not perfect because I’m writing for fun and not worrying about it. I had someone dm me once on Discord offering to beta read to fix my “very obvious gammer issues since I had so much potential” and I actually haven’t written since and I can’t write without thinking about how bad it is, this wasn’t even a fic I posted online it was of my oc x canon that I shared in a server
2026-07-04 17:10:36
200
_moonchild_ :
I "corrected" someone's fic once and it was only because the author said that they are open to suggestions and corrections and asked for feedback. It was in the HP fandom, where James Potter used a spell invented by Severus Snape and I asked in the comments if the plot of James stealing his notes and the spells Severus invented might be expanded because it would really add into the story (also because in canon James does use a spell invented by Severus). The author responded by thanking me for catching the "plot hole" and saying that it wasn't intended and she doesn't have a plan for it, but she just might write something around it later. I would never write such a comment on a fan work that did not invite this form of feedback and it still surprises me that someone would even consider doing it.
2026-07-04 21:02:52
24
acorn :
literally yes. what i post is the final results of me already combing through something and editing it to be the way i want it to be. i do not post fanfic to get feedback on the quality, i literally post it for fun and to contribute to the fandom. the one time
2026-07-04 16:30:14
195
LemonyLeaf :
If you love something. You probably want that writer to keep writing and they probably know their own flaws better than you so just give them encouragement and keep your criticism to yourself if they've not asked. It ain't that hard.
2026-07-05 01:58:03
58
Atlantis :
As a writer I love when people give ideas for the stories direction, but I HATE feedback on my writing style or what I've already done. But I could genuinely never imagine leaving any kind of feedback on someone's work
2026-07-04 22:33:04
17
isimarie2201 :
If you really enjoy giving feedback on fics offer to betaread! Outside of that if authors aren’t asking for feedback in the notes don’t just give it 😭
2026-07-04 17:10:21
115
splookie :
the one time i "corrected" an author was when autocorrect diabolically had changed hoseok into hoe sock at a very serious moment in the fic and i couldn't NOT laught about that in the comments
2026-07-04 22:50:19
4
wawa⁷ :
Genuinely the equivalent of posting a cake you made online and someone judging it like you’re a baker?? Like? It’s for fun.
2026-07-04 17:38:49
47
Olympe :
when I love a fic so much I comment omg I love this so much not "actually you could've done this better" 💀
2026-07-04 17:17:44
20
☀️☀️☀️ :
as a reader all I want is to know when there will be a new chapter and or if you've dropped it. because id be waiting 😔
2026-07-04 22:06:28
9
Ari :
the only comments I ever leave are "this is peak". if I don't find something peak I don't comment
2026-07-04 22:25:02
13
Leland 🦌🫀 :
The concept of leaving criticism on something that you read made for free out of the authors own time and want is crazy to me. Gives I’m insanely entitled and annoying
2026-07-05 11:25:22
11
Maruska :
if I ever wrote a critical comment on a fic I would never forgive myself
2026-07-05 16:12:05
32
Denise ❯❯❯❯❯ ♾️ :
The only reason to ever critique on ao3 is to request the tags be changed if they are misleading. That’s it.
2026-07-06 07:45:34
11
To see more videos from user @schemingbanshee2.0, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
